Snakebites wrote:Laimbeer wrote:Penny
Harden
Luka
That seem to be the pecking order. Luka gets knocked for living in an offensive scheme people can't envision or don't think maximizes other high level talent. Harden is poked for his D and ball dominance. Penny seems most popular, imo.
I think Harden is better than Penny. Probably not relative to cost though. Penny gets knocked for fit too.
All of them are primary ball handlers who need to guard wings most of the time which can be a challenge to navigate.
As for ball dominance, all three have track records alongside other ball handlers- most notably Harden with CP3, older Penny with Kidd, and Luka with Brunson (not ready to call Kyrie a success).
I've got Harden and Luka over Penny without a doubt, it's just that they're also far more expensive (especially Luka).
Harden gives you more flexibility than Luka - he's had points where he played a similarly extreme style, but he's also functioned in a wider variety of roles and systems. (I do think Luka working well with Brunson and even more so with Kyrie are encouraging signals.) On the other hand, Luka has another gear he can consistently get to in the playoffs, while Harden has a spottier history with a bunch of weird moments. I guess I prefer Luka in a vacuum, but I would have been fine taking either at that spot.