Vinsanity_GOAT wrote:BmanInBigD wrote:JVL wrote:
Do you consider Duncan a C or are you deliberately disrespecting him? There's just no way Duncan is not in any top 5 all-time PF list.
I noticed that too. But when I saw Chris Webber on there at 3 and Rodman on there at 4, it all made sense.
Did you see Chris Webber when he was at his prime? Obviously he didn't end up having a top 5 career, but listing him as a top 5 talent isn't that far fetched. He could've been the best pf imo, if he would've had the right attitude.
Rodman had a huge positive impact for his teams, there's more to basketball than scoring and stats...
I excluded mchale because i haven't seen enough of him to form an opinion. And Barkley imo gets massively overrated, from what i've seen he didn't play too much defense and the only reason he's become such a mythical player is because of the height nonsense. Sure he was undersized but not nearly as much as he likes to claim. His standing reach was definitely above average for the position.
Webber MIGHT have been a top 5 talent, but I thought this was more about what they actually DID. Maybe I was wrong.
And if you think that Rodman had as much positive impact as Dirk and it just depends on your offensive/defensive preference, I'd bet every coach and GM in the history of ever (well, except maybe Isaiah Thomas ) would disagree with you.