ciueli wrote:JB7 wrote:Michael Bradley wrote:
The issue is, Masai isn't 2013-19 Masai right now, he's 2020-24 Masai. If the Raptors were to replace him, they'd be replacing a clearly inferior executive than the one who was a top 3 exec in the league prior to 2020. It's not like the Raptors are churning out 2nd round picks that turn into starters, or hitting on their mid/late 1st round picks anymore. They probably do require some type of shift in their front office (whether Masai or scouting) as their success rate in developing talent from 2013-19 vs today is night and day.
From a sentimental standpoint, I'm a Masai guy and am rooting for him to build this team back up. He might not get the chance to, but if that's the case then it would be far more justifiable to replace him now than it would have been a few years ago.
You do realize the huge distinction between pre- and post-championship, right?
They had to sacrifice a lot of their assets to obtain that championship, which has resulted in the teams poor performance 2 years post championship. But he has still managed to obtain some key pieces to build around again (i.e. Barnes). Give him a few more years to build the asset base back up.
That's the whole problem, though, he's not really trying to build up the asset base, he's trying to get the team into the play-in and even the playoffs the next two seasons. If he's successful in this, it means weakening the asset base, not strengthening it as the team winds up drafting outside the lottery for the foreseeable future, not playing young players in real games in order to win now, and potentially even trading away future draft picks to fill more holes in the short term. The Kelly Olynyk trade is evidence of all three of those points I just made (trading picks to win now, veteran taking minutes from prospects, improving win/loss record that means worse draft position).
I'm not saying this approach can't work, it can if the right deal comes along or the right players are drafted with later picks, but it's a difficult plan to succeed with because it's harder to get star talent later in the draft and players who are ready to win now are more expensive than young players on rookie deals leaving less financial flexibility to fill out the starting lineup and bench.
2018-19: win chip
2019-20: maintain much of roster, outside of Kawhi & Green because Masai was positioning the team to have cap space to pursue Giannis if he became available.
2020-21: Covid year in Tampa, Giannis signs extension in Dec 2020 and Masai pivots to tank half way through the season and Raps get lucky with 4th pick and draft Barnes
2021-22: Probably the year everybody questions, whether Masai should have moved all his assets (Pascal, OG, & FVV) for picks and youth. This is a point of debate. Should Scottie's 1st year in the league be a complete **** show? I can see Masai's point in trying to have a relevant roster around a young potential star. But there is the problem of fit with Pascal.
2022-23: Looks like he was shopping Pascal & Fred around, with no real substantial returns, and ends up trading for Yak (team desperately needing a C). End of the season, Houston drops the bag on Fred's lap. Wise move for Masai not to match that offer.
2023-24: Unload's Pascal and OG for IQ, RJ & picks
2024-25: Starting with a base of Barnes, IQ, RJ, Dick, Yak, Ja'Kobe, and Raps have all their picks going into stronger upcoming drafts, along with Indy's pick.
Not a bad job considering Kawhi walked after winning the chip with the Raps, and Giannis resigned in Milwaukee.