seren wrote:bronxknicksfan1 wrote:seren wrote:What an awful trade. I don’t see a single thing KAT does better than Randle and we lost valuable depth and gave away a first round pick in the process. Very difficult to come back from a blunder like this financially. We went from a deep team with a lot of grit to an overpaid squad with lots of injury history. I don’t want to hyperbole too much but this team is one injury away from McDyess years.
Better scorer, better rebounder, better shooter, better defender. He’s better at everything except passing.
As a Knicks fan, I truly wish this was true but unfortunately I watched KAT enough to know he is pretty much a disappointment. If the center was such a big need, it would have been better to go after Gobert. At least he delivers on the defensive end. KAT plays little of it and he is quite easy to stop on the offensive end with a smaller player. Add the injuries and constant foul troubles, expect to see lots of Sims and Precious this season.
Which part isn’t true? Randle hasn’t been better than KAT at any of those things in his career. I’ve had a chance to watch KAT my fair share as well. He spaces the floor tremendously. He can catch and shoot, he can pick and roll/pop, he can come off screens and set them. And he’s been a much better, more efficient scorer than Randle has ever been. KAT being a sieve doesn’t make as much a different since Randle was on better. If anything, he’s shown even less effort than KAT on that end, who looked good next to Gobert. Wouldn’t be surprised if he plays next to Mitch in some lineups once he’s back. The issue with him is foul trouble as you mentioned, which I’m sure Randle would see himself in if he ever played C.