HartfordWhalers wrote:gswhoops wrote:Wholeheartedly disagree that this is a win-win for Houston. Honestly it feels like a lose-lose.
If the last couple months of last season were a fluke then they're commited to paying $35M a year for 3 years for an inefficient iso scorer who doesn't do anything else well. Basically the Jordan Poole contract volume 2, except for more money.
If he does turn out to be that guy, they've only got one more year committed before he hits FA.
I am fully with this take. If you are not ready to commit to 4(+) seasons, then roll it forward a year and do this next summer. But surrendering future control and still paying ahead of knowing if he is a max player or not, all seems like a bad return on the ~6m they are saving per year below a 3 year max as is.
nate33 wrote:Seems like a pretty terrible deal from Houston's perspective. Green, although physically talented, is not really a very good player yet, so in the short term, this is an overpay. And if Green does put it all together in the next year or two, he becomes an unrestricted free agent in 2 years just as Houston is facing a salary crisis with Sengun, Thompson, Smith, Whitmore and Eason all hitting their second contracts.
I just don't see much upside for Houston on this. I would have waited until next summer. if he turns the corner and become a max-worthy player, then pay him the max then and you'd have him locked up for 5 years. If he hasn't turned the corner, then pay him his fair value or let him walk in free agency if someone else overpays for him. By making this extension now, they effectively have the worst of both worlds. If he fizzles, they're stuck overpaying him for 3 years. If he breaks out, they've only saved a couple of million over the next 2 seasons and then risk losing him as an unrestricted free agent.
Yeah this is essentially my take away. The more I think about this deal the more I hate it for Houston.
I think this argument gets overused here, but Green really is the prototypical candidate for a team to play "wait and see" with and let him go to RFA rather than extend early. He's shown flashes of being a max player but hasn't put it together consistently. If he can keep up his late-season heroics over the course of an entire season, then they'd happily max him next offseason (and they'd be at no risk of losing him because he'd be a RFA).