prophet_of_rage wrote:GONYK wrote:prophet_of_rage wrote:Then what does Deuce do? Deuce will handle the ball more than Mikal. And you can play 5 out with Hart. It isn't just stand and sling 3s. Deuce and Mikal aren't particular spectqcular at that.
You have no dirty work guy or sacrifice guy with that lineup. Mikal.is better as captiqn of the second unit like RJ.
Sent from my SM-S9080 using
RealGM mobile app
You can't play 5 out with Hart. Nobody guards Hart on the perimeter and we shouldn't be catering our entire offense around getting Hart into the action in order to get his man away from the rim.
Deuce becomes the sacrifice guy. He doesn't bring the rebounding and transition play, but he doesn't bring much better defense, shooting and
overall team spacing.
This debate is pointless because it is theoretical. No matter where you stand, we should have had the answer to this question one way or another by now.
You absolutely can play 5 out with Hart. 5 ouy isn't every man standing around the 3 point line and their men hugging them. You can use Hart as a weakside cutter or screener and consider his man in help so you can drive and dish yo him cutting in. He can off ball screen so man can get to the middle. He can drive it himself and make a read. He can handoff or hit cutters since there's no pressure on his passing.
There's always going to be bodies in the paint aginst a 5 out offence. The weakside defenders will collapse in the paint on any drive.
Sent from my SM-S9080 using
RealGM mobile app
You can't play 5 out with Josh off the ball if he's not making threes. Good teams put their center on him. This is what an actual 5 out offense looks like -

They're starting their offense 30 feet from the basket, because every single player is behind the 3 point line and the opposing center cannot just leave KP.
This is how good teams treat Hart when he doesn't have the ball

Sengun is below the foul line, not even thinking about him.

Look at how far Mobley is off him, he's got both feet in the paint
If you replaced Hart with a good shooter, the floor balance shifts and guys can't have both feet in the paint if that shooter is in the corner. The Cavs have two bigs, which hurts us because we're small and ontop of that Hart isn't a good / willing shooter. Against other good teams, they continue to put their center on him, and the only way to combat that is have him on the ball a lot or pray that he's willing to take threes. In the playoffs last season he made them, at the start of this season he was making them, since the new year he's shooting 28% on threes.
If Hart doesn't make the three he's a liability against good teams when he's off ball, it's why he's second on the team in touches per game. He has to have the ball to be respected.