RipCity71252 wrote:clyde21 wrote:RipCity71252 wrote:I can't believe I'm re-explaining this. Narrow chest and shoulders understate arm length. That is the length the previous poster was referring to. I know this because he and oned my posts.
If two players have the same wingspan but one has a very narrow chest and shoulder region. Who do you think has a longer arm length?
And please just answer the question.
Do you think you're doing something with that question? No **** the dude with the smaller shoulders would have the longer arms in that scenario. You're not adding any new ideas to the conversation here my guy.
And no, narrow shoulders don't understand arm length because arm length is measured FROM the shoulder. That's why wingspan measurements exist because they *include* shoulders in the measurements.
It's honestly weird af what you're arguing but again that's what happens when you hijack a conversation without understanding what was being argued
Sorry I meant narrow chest and shoulders understate arm length when referring to just a wingspan measurement.
I'm sorry my previous post didn't already make that clear.
But hey we're getting somewhere.
So if two guys have the same wingspan but one has longer arms would you say that wingspan measurement of a player with a narrow chest and shoulder region is underestimating that player's length? Since players apply their length in many other ways other than with their arms out wide?
yes, narrow shoulders can understate wingspan, no one ever argued that, but that wasn't what original argument was.
again, the original argument was this:
Guys like Noa Essengue, Mikal Bridges, and Tayshaun Prince have narrow shoulders and therefore have wingspans that understate their "length."
if the argument is narrow shoulders = shorter wingspan then we agree
if the argument is "wingspan understates length" then we don't agree.
wingspan is strictly a measurement of arm length + shoulder width. nothing more nothing less.
and it sounds like we agree