VaDe255 wrote:Crazy-Canuck wrote:People calling herro a defender is wild to me.
Bane isn't a great defender, might not even be a good one. But, he can at least guard his position.That is definitely something herro cant do.
Bane got what he got because he spaces the floor and can hold his own on defense. Magic badly needed that amd went out and over paid for it. Herro gives you more creativity and shot making, but just too many defensive leaks to cover up for.
The magic saw an opportunity and took their shots. He slides in perfectly with Suggs, Pablo, and Wagner.
Bane came into the league later and is 1.5y older than Tyler.
Sure, you can make a case for Bane being better on defense, but at the same time he's not as talented on offense.
Just depends on what you want from a guy, I think Heat would turn that offer down (and maybe did). We'll never know but Herro would have been a better fit with how much defense there already is on Orlando and how badly they lack shot creation.
If they turned that down, they are better off being the gleague team for the Hornets.
The offensive gap between the 2 are negligible. Herro has a bigger bag, but he doesn't have a role outside of 6th man on a contender. Bane is much easier to fit him. He's stable, can shoot, and guard his man. He isn't a no.1, but he'd be a great no.2/3.
Herro is either a first option or 6th man. He doesn't do enough on the other side of the ball to be worth his contract to play as a no.2 or no.3.
Imo, every contender would take bane over herro. I don't even think it's an argument.