Your Final 4

[Bigdog1]

Twin vs yankees

phils vs cards

[VinnyTheMick]

Phils vs. Giants (I think the Giants win the west & in a 3 game series I don't see any team beating that rotation)

Yankees vs. Rays (honestly, it could just as easily be the Angels instead of the Rays)

Yankees vs. Phillies in the WS again.

[Bigdog1]

linceum,cain, sanchez,?

that is pretty dirty

I Like the cards though coming out of the west

Wainright, Carp isn't bad at all

cards vs yanks

yanks in 7

[VinnyTheMick]

linceum,cain, sanchez,?

that is pretty dirty

I Like the cards though coming out of the west

Wainright, Carp isn't bad at all

cards vs yanks

yanks in 7

Cards in the central but I feel you.

[Wade2k6]

Rockies-Phillies
Yankees-Red Sox

Yankees- Phillies (God I hope so) Yankees in 7.

[Greatness]

Yankees - Rays
Phillies - Cards

Yankees - Cards

[craig01]

Red Sox..... Rays.

Cards......Phillies

Rays.....Cards


Yes, I am a homer....lol

[Klomp]

Twins - Red Sox
Cardinals - Giants

Twins - Cardinals

[CentralQB5]

Phlls vs Cards for NL
Yanks vs BoSox for AL ( dispite the Sox early struggles i think they will still pull through )

WS = Phils and Yanks once again....this time is ends different Phillies win it

[Relentless88]

Phils - Giants
Yankees - Red Sox

Yankees - Phillis

[Bay_Areas_Finest]

Seattle Mariners
New York Yankees

Philadelphia Phillies
St Louis Cardinals

---

Phillies over Yankees

[cb4_89]

Yankees and Phillies. I think Roy Halladay was an amazing pick up by the phils. And he knows the yankees and has faced them many times as a jay.

Phils win title

[VinnyTheMick]

Yankees and Phillies. I think Roy Halladay was an amazing pick up by the phils. And he knows the yankees and has faced them many times as a jay.

Phils win title

My problem with this logic is that Cliff Lee pitched about as well as anyone could against the Yankees in the last world series. So let's say Roy matches that, or even outperforms that.....that's still only 2 wins. Where do the other wins come from?

I just don't see how the Phillies have leapfrogged the Yankees.

[Wade2k6]

I agree and that's usually the point I use when arguing about that with my friends (who are Philly fans). Only advantage I can think of is that he can pitch on 3 days rest, where Lee couldn't.

[CentralQB5]

Yankees and Phillies. I think Roy Halladay was an amazing pick up by the phils. And he knows the yankees and has faced them many times as a jay.

Phils win title

My problem with this logic is that Cliff Lee pitched about as well as anyone could against the Yankees in the last world series. So let's say Roy matches that, or even outperforms that.....that's still only 2 wins. Where do the other wins come from?

I just don't see how the Phillies have leapfrogged the Yankees.

Ok if Roy does match what Lee did ( even if he does better ) it will all depend on the rest of the rotation especailly Cole