Severn Hoos wrote:Chocolate City Jordanaire wrote:BigA wrote:The Wizboard is one of the most level-headed, sophisticated forums I've encountered on the web. I don't think we've ever had an actual issue with spreading/running with sketchy info.
So I'm not sure a preemptive, heavy-handed policy is really called for to address a hypothetical problem. But I'm on the free speech side of things. I think the community here has shown itself to be strong enough to merit some latitude.
The mods, of course, have the power to deal with any specific situations that come up as they see fit.
Big A, I appreciate the way you've put this. I didn't post yesterday because I might have launched a Dan Gilbert-like, emotionally-charged response. I'm still a bit emotional about this. Here's the best I've got today:
pineapplehead, it's so nice of you to think for the little people who don't know how to express themselves. I know that it's just imperative to not have any baseless gossip spread on the Wizards Board.
Censor away. Pontificate. Let folks know who's the man, pine
Hey CCJ, can I quote you over in the Politics thread re; Fairness Doctrine, Internet regulation, Campaign Finance laws, etc.? I happen to agree completely in the sense that the cure for "bad" speech is not less speech, but more speech. Allow the marketplace of ideas to sort it out and let people think for themselves. I just find it ironic that some of those who would be the first to protest a library using an internet filter to keep child porn off of the computers in the children's section would not only accept but promote an idea such as the Fairness Doctrine, "for the greater good."
Now - that being said, I do understand some of pine's motivation here. I took his post to be more in the spirit of "C'mon guys, we're better than that. We don't need to lower ourselves with the rest of the gutter-dwellers and engage in rumor-mongering." I have no problem with that statement, provided it does not actually move into censorship, banning, etc. Again, the best remedy is more speech. Call out the rumor-mongers and haters. Expose them for spreading lies and encouraging the worst elements of message boards. Mock them, even. I heartily endorse that approach.
Sev, I didn't take them that way. I have my reasons for saying this. No need, but to say pine, feel free to contact me offline if you wish. Otherwise, I'm done with it.