Ayt wrote:-= original quote snipped =-
Why let him hit lefties? Mench is struggling versus righties, but he's still killing lefties.
What should happen is Gross and Gwynn play over Mench against righties. There is no reason to have Shrek play against righties just as there is no reason for Jenkins to hit lefties.
Jenkins hit .133 against lefties last year and is hitting .158 against them this year. Why would you possibly want that in the lineup when Mench and Hart both rake against lefties?
Well Hart should be in the line up every day, so that's a moot point.

And Jenks is much better than Gross or Gwynn vs. righties, so I don't see that happening either. The problem then, is you'd have a Mench/Jenkins/Gross/Gwynn platoon in one spot, and that's pretty ridiculous. I'm fine with platoons to a point, but Mench just looks lost out there right now. Jenkins isn't the greatest vs lefties, fine. But Gross and Gwynn are also left handed, and Jenkins has shown signs of improvement vs. lefties. There is no reason not to have him out there every day once Hart is healthy.