ComboGuardCity wrote:magnumt wrote:So I plan to upgrade my mom's phone soon for her. I'll be getting her a TOuchscreen Phone next, and we're on Sprint. Here's what I've narrowed it down too (leaning towards #1):
1) Samsung Epic™ 4G
2) HTC EVO™ 4G
Thoughts?
Thanks,
--Mags
P.S. The new lines of Android Phones won't be an option for her (for me yes, but not her).
I went through the same thing 4 months ago. The EVO is the better device. Literally the same exact debate. Do not let the specs full you. Sammy may have the SAMOLED screen, but the difference is negligible. Its interface is alot friendlier than Samsung's touch wiz which will make it easier on her. In addition, the phone feels a lot sturdier in the hand. The samsung feels like cheap plastic imo. If she needs the keyboard then consider the Epic. If not, the EVO is the superior device.
AndroidMan wrote:If its between those 2 devices, then it's no contest. Epic 4g hands down.
Humingbird processor(epic) is much better then the snapdragon found on the evo. Your mom may not do any gaming, but the graphics embedded chip on the evo is utter crap. The epic has a much better screen. I believe the epic comes preinstalled with Swype. Has a better camera.
Touchwiz's interface is fine. Also, Samsung devices support almost all video formats. Try loading a 720p mkv on it and it will play flawlessly. Pure sex with the samoled display.
I've had friends on Sprint ask me the same questions months ago and I directed them towards the epic. My answer has still not changed, although these days I'd recommend waiting for some dual core beast. The Galaxy S 2 is not too far away from being released, nor is the Nexus S 4g.

Two differing opinions.

Combo, yeah I saw that too...the HTC is REALLY built for speed and userbility via the interface (even it's predecessor the Shift and Hero aren't as "stocked" as it is).
Android, yeah that's why I'm leaning towards the Epic as it'll last a little bit longer and has a better screen. The HTC is at the peak of its Product Lifecycle right now. With the Epic she gets the more Battery friendly Hummingbird Processor combined with a Battery friendly GPU. And with her job (non-Office), the ability to not have to recharge as often as she would with the HTC (which has a 6 Hr Battery life I believe) would be a VERY nice edge.
Some more thoughts on this from you guys (or others) would be great. Thanks!

--Mags