Pimpwerx wrote:GreenHat wrote:You're blaming the offense on Wade/Lebron/Bosh? They are the reason our offense is any good. When has Spo shown he can create a good offense without superstars?
And our teams in the early years had plenty of defensive talent. It wasn't all Spo. Unless you think Spo is a much better defensive coach than Riley?
I also agree that we beat teams last year that we were supposed to lose to. That's a blatant misrepresentation. We were favored against every team. We were the overall favorite. What team did we beat that we were supposed to lost to? We were supposed to beat all of those teams and the Mavs too.
The differences between Spo and Coughlin is that Coughlin won it all and didn't have the best talent in the league. Coughlin was also successful with other teams. Plus coaching matters more in football and superstars matter more in basketball.
I'm not blaming anyone. Unlike you, I'm not playing the lame blame game. Every team loses some games. **** happens. Every team goes into slumps. **** **** happens. This team had the killer pace and space early and was the #1 halfcourt offense just in early March. THIS SAME TEAM WITH THIS SAME COACH *gasp*.
Spo may not have coached great offense without superstars, but not many coaches do. What he did do was coach a Top10 defense out of scrubs, and that was sufficient to give him two straight playoff appearances with winning records. It allowed him to only coach 12 games in 3 years where his team has a losing record. OFFENSE ISN'T EVERYTHING. Get over your obsession and understand he's plenty good enough with offense and awesome with defense.
Spo might be a better defensive coach than Riley. He's only in his 3rd season, but look how quickly he got the team from the 26th defense to the 11th with little more than Wade's return. In his first 3 seasons, I'd wager he is statistically a better defensive coach, but I don't have the stats to back that up.
We weren't favored against all teams, the same as this year. I think we were favorites last year, and I think the same thing this season, but that's my optimism. There is more than enough pessimism regarding this team (a lot of it eminating from this forum) that I don't need to point it out. If we're favored to beat everyone, then the pessimism (and thus the stupid complaints about Spo) are unwarranted. I mean...we're just gonna Big3 everyone to death, right? **** Spo, amirite?
Coughlin was criticized before he won anything. Don't try any rewrite history here. Coughlin was been bashed from Day1 in Gotham. And unless we forget, he had 3 straight losing seasons before he was fired from JVille. Don't act like he walked into NYC with a sparkling resume. He was run out of Jacksonville, and even after winning his first Superbowl, the Giants fans still wanted him fired. The Post was calling for his firing just this season. I mean, the guy's job will be under fire again next year. Some guys just can't win, regardless of merit, and Spo is one of those guys. You guys are ignoring the facts and riding the hate you've had for the guy since he was hired.
I didn't like the hire at first, and I was skeptical at the start of last season too. But the guy has more than earned my respect. I'm not sure what else he could do other than win the championship, and even then you would be clamoring for Riley to replace him. PEACE.
I literally said in the other post you quoted that Spo wasn't the reason we lost to the Mavs and that he gets too much blame when we lose. How is that playing the "lame blame game".
You on the other hand did blame those guys for our offense. They have all been centerpieces of top 5 offenses without Spo. Now all together they are a top 5 offense. How is that a mark in his favor? All three of them have anchored a top 5 offense by themselves. Bottom line is we are 5th in offense with all three of them.
My obsession with offense? I think you have me confused with someone else. I'm literally the opposite because I see offense as having a higher variance. And those "scrubs" included a lot of good defensive players. Wade, Haslem, Anthony, Marion, JO, Chalmers, Qrich, Dorrell. Especially compared to guys like Ricky Davis, Mark Blount and Jwill. And again if you are saying the change is coaching and not players then you are saying Spo is a much better coach than Riley. I totally disagree with that.
And you keep saying that the only change was "the return of Wade" but that is BS. Wade came back way better and played 1000 more minutes. Ricky Davis played 3000 less minutes. Blount played 1500 less minutes. JWILL played 1900 less minutes. They added Chalmers, Beasley, Marion/JO (not at same time) and an extra 1000 minutes of Wade instead of d-league guys. How can you say these teams were similar?
We were favorites last year and this year because of our talent, not because of your optimism. We have the most talent in the league. If we had a better coach we would be even heavier favorites. My only complaint about Spo is he isn't near the best coach in the league. Since we have the best talent in the league already and there is a salary cap on players we should be able to have the best team in the league and coaching is one way for us to improve.
I'm not rewriting history. Coughlin did have a couple of 11 win seasons along with a 14 win season in Jacksonville. I don't care what some idiot fans or writers think, I've always had him as a good coach. And he did that without an overwhelming talent advantage. And as I said coaching matters more in football and superstars matter more in basketball. If he had as much of an advantage in talent as Spo has he would have a near perfect season. Coughlin has more "merit" than Spo.
I have no hate for Spo. I have said he was an above average coach many times, including in response to you saying I hated him. It seems you are the one ignoring facts because you are trying to say those teams when he first took over were the same as the 15 win team when they aren't really close to being the same at all.
I don't want Riley to replace him either so again I have no idea who you are mistaking me for. And again the bottom line is he didn't actually win a championship as of yet, even though he had the best talent in the league and was favored to. As I said in a previous post I don't blame him for the loss but he did contribute to it.
Your emotions fuel the narratives that you create. You see what you want to see. You believe what you want to believe. You ascribe meaning when it is not there. You create significance when it is not present.