NavLDO wrote:If you or others want to 'pin' our problems on the players, well, yes, you are correct if the 'teacher', in this case the coach, is providing the correct instruction, and the 'students', in this case, the players, are not responding appropriately by not effectively implementing the coach's instruction on the court, then the worst offenders need to be sat, or in extreme cases traded...OR, the coach needs to be changed to one that might be able to properly motivate the players to play how they are instructed to.
Either way, what's happening now is unacceptable. And if Horny is to be the 'scapegoat', then fine, but good luck in expecting any great miracle changes to happen unless about 3-4 players are also replaced. I personally, would get rid of these non-compliant players first and give Horny a chance to turn it around; and if not replacing Horny turns out to be the wrong choice, then replace Horny.
Sounds easy, right? Well, no, I get that it's not that easy, but for goodness sakes, do SOMETHING!
I agree with what you say but it's tough, when probably the two worst offenders of guys not on the table are Bledsoe and Knight. It's pretty evident in what the coaches, Price, etc say, that it's them that fail to do the right thing, do the play called, or when the play breaks down, which seems often, adapt smartly and quickly.
So if it's them, it is kind of tough to trade them for several reasons. First, the league is loaded with PGs. Secondly, McD would look stupid to trade Knight after giving up what he did for him, and it could make it tougher to sign free agents if him OR Bledsoe were traded. I don't know if sitting them helps a ton.
I am skeptical on them becoming much smarter with time, but that seems to be the thing I am hoping for because I don't think either will be traded. Part of me wants to say that only one should be on the court at a time or at least they should never both sit at the same time, but then, on the other hand, Knight is better suited as a SG.
I mean, maybe another coach can suddenly make them a lot smarter, but I certainly wouldn't bet money on that. But, a guy like Carlisle seems to do that, for example, Felton and Jameer Nelson played in Dallas last year under him and were not all that good. But after a year under him, they both are playing well this year, Felton still in Dallas and Nelson in Denver. If we do a trade I wouldn't mind getting Jameer Nelson in, just as a mentor for the guards, and perhaps to play sometimes if/when one gets benched due to stupid play.
But that is also why I was looking at Melvin Hunt, asst coach to Carlisle and also has worked on player development and been under some other good coaches like Karl.
Karl is actually another good example of how hard it is to coach stupid players. He has been to the ECF with Milwaukee, the NBA finals with Seattle, took Denver to a 3 seed five or so years ago which was very surprising. But now with Sacramento, with a combo of young and dumb players, he is having a tough time getting them past even 500, as have all coaches with those players, even though, on paper they have a lot of raw talent.
However, they may get smarter over time, regardless of who is coach, but if this happens I think Hornacek is a good coach to have. I'd just REALLY hate to gamble on another coach who ends up being worse.