LKN wrote:MJ2Rose wrote:But it’s all relative and Michael would have access to all of those things too if he played in this era. His game was also about so much more than athleticism. It was also about his competitive drive, fundamentals, leadership, mental fortitude and skill all in one package. No doubt Lebron is more of a physical freak but he’s 3-6 in the finals, should be 2-7, and I think Kyrie was more the reason they beat Golden State. I would’ve loved to see how his career unfolded if he played out West his entire career.
I think Jordan would be even better in today’s game because it’s easier to drive to the lane. Less physical and big men are often pulled further out to defend. Jordan was averaging over 30 ppg in an era where the average points scored in a game was far less than it is now.
Players are not "wildly more athletic now", particularly superstars. If there's been a change it's been teams doing a better job finding bench players. Shaq, MJ, etc would still be every bit the athletic freaks they were in their own eras and even more - would get all the benefits of modern training, analytics, etc.
I mean it's just basic biology - humans are not getting more athletic over time (although a larger population means you have a slightly better chance of finding freak outliers I suppose(
Fellows,
Is it a certainty that MJ goes 6/6 if he doesn't get drafted by Jerry Krauss @ no.3 in 1984? Are you sure he doesn't self destruct in his own head, and still does it without getting the help of Doug Collins, Phil, Cartwright, Scottie, Dennis, Kukoc, Paxon, Kerr, Harper, etc exactly when he did? Does he ever win a title, forget 6/6 or 3/9, if he gets drafted by present day MJ / Magic / Dan Gilbert / Jim Dolan if he doesn't go out and form a super team.
Sure, Lebron was dumb enough to come back to that situation and waste another 4 years trying to win one for the "LAND", rather than go to the Spurs / Warriors, but let's just put that aside as we do MJ's multiple retirements.
For the extreme competitiveness, killer instinct and mental fortitude he lacks, Lebron's still attempted and hit more game winners in the playoffs and regular season at a higher clip, not even counting the right passes made to team mates. And he has come back from a 3-1 finals deficit against a 73 win arguably a top 1/2 team ever. Mike's Bulls only ever trailed twice from game 1 losses to Lakers and Jazz; Never in Game 3 / 5.
Mike's probably the closest to perfect in his technique, shooting form, bottom line efficiency in every individual move, and boy did he have a motor - the sick game, the unearthly minutes he could play the other team's best guard 1-on-1 and still have energy to takeover at the end of games.
Lebron is unquestionably a better leader with a higher game IQ who makes average/below average players around him better(Think Delly, Mike Miller, Shane Battier, JR, TT, Shump, Chris Anderson, RJ, Channing Frye, Dwight and f*cking Timofey Mozgov) and net negative but good players like Kyrie and K-Love look like superstars. You think any of these role players go into Mike/Kobe's gas chamber and come out so good. Cuckoo Kyrie and KD only liked Kobe on TV and afar on another team. Why do you think none of them ever tried to play with him? Cos Kobe/Mike would send them packing to their Mama cos they're soft. Kyrie complained about Lebron when he left and KD can't stop whining about Steve Kerr, Steph Curry and the Warriors now.
The playoff finals record is 6/6 vs 3/9 sure.. but Lebron, with worse teams, got to 3 more finals; 2 more ECFs in the same number of playoff appearances, and never with the best coach in the time, the best number 2 player(Top 25 all time) and the best rebounder / DPOY. He's only gone to the finals as the oddsmakers favourite twice(Miami 2011 & 2012), compared to MJ's 6/6 finals with a superior team that never got taken to a a game 7, and won 55 games without him.
There's a lot of decisions / variables / luck / timing involved in any players legacy. Let's not create extreme hyperbolic godly narratives of one guy's mental fortitude and killer instinct and competitiveness, which just don't add up.
And if you think Kyrie and Horry and Paxon and Ray Allen won those championships with Lebron, Kobe, Shaq, Duncan, Paker, Manu and Mike hanging on to their coat tails, cos they took the last shot, Good Luck to you my friends.
















