I wanted to float something out here...
I am all for defund and reimagine the PF. But I am thinking this should apply to any local, state or federal program or institution.
I am going to pick schools as a comparison example (go figure

).
A local community has a theoretical population of 100K. They have a failing school system and a failing PF.
Defunding and then reimaging the PF makes total sense. Rebuild it against what you actually want to accomplish now. The previous PF was probably established with different goals. That doesn't mean you can't have a PF that unionized - it would just need to be a different union with different rules and protections.
Same with a failing school or school district (SD). Defunding and reimagining makes total sense here as well. Rebuild it to look at the current objectives. The previous SD was probably established with goals from the 50s. Reimagine what that SD should accomplish now. Again, that doesn't mean you can't have a SD that unionized - it would just need to be a different union with different rules and protections.
The losers in this might be individual police officers or teachers. The biggest loser is going to be the unions. To do this the local governments would need cover from the voters to take this on. Are we ready for that.
And if we are honest, defunding and reimagining our institutions need to happen fairly often given the rapidly increasing changes to the world.
Thoughts?