KnixtapeH20 wrote:3toheadmelo wrote:I’m still traumatized from 2014 Raymond felton
I'm still traumatized by 2000s Chris Duhon
I'm still traumatized by Howard Eisley, and him ruining Antonio McDyess's knee.
Moderators: j4remi, HerSports85, NoLayupRule, GONYK, Jeff Van Gully, dakomish23, Deeeez Knicks, mpharris36

KnixtapeH20 wrote:3toheadmelo wrote:I’m still traumatized from 2014 Raymond felton
I'm still traumatized by 2000s Chris Duhon
Eisley might have been the worst.nykinoz wrote:KnixtapeH20 wrote:3toheadmelo wrote:I’m still traumatized from 2014 Raymond felton
I'm still traumatized by 2000s Chris Duhon
I'm still traumatized by Howard Eisley, and him ruining Antonio McDyess's knee.
nykballa2k4 wrote:KnixtapeH20 wrote:prophet_of_rage wrote:It actually isn't. We have had way worse point guards. Toure Murray. Frank Williams. Scott Brooks. Brooks Thompson. Shane Larkin.
Sent from my SM-N970W using Tapatalk
I'd take Toure' Murray over Elfrid bc he actually plays defense. Yes its another player we hyped up but he was also a product of the NYK environment. Larkin could actually shoot he was just 4 foot
None of those players u mentioned were shoved down our throats to play 40 minutes on a contending team.
Frank was awesome. Wish we kept him and didn't get Crawful.
thebuzzardman wrote:KnixtapeH20 wrote:3toheadmelo wrote:I’m still traumatized from 2014 Raymond felton
I'm still traumatized by 2000s Chris Duhon
Who is the award winning worst Knick point guard since 1990? Criteria is ineptitude, length of service and minutes per game.
nykballa2k4 wrote:3toheadmelo wrote:KnicksGadfly wrote:
Like Melo didn’t want to ruin his payday when he forced a trade and got the Knicks to give up a shytton of assets? Or how “social justice warrior” Melo somehow felt comfortable calling out the only Asian American player in the NBA for a ridiculous contract? Of course he didn’t do it to anyone else, of course. Or how the Knicks ended up trading for Felton to appease him?
Or you feel it’s okay for a minimum player who was about to cut from the league, sleeping on a friend’s coach, to risk his career for a jealous 100 million+ player who didn’t like him and went out of his way to alienate and remove him from the team anyway? The one who got ridden by Mike D’Antoni like Secretariat to help the Knicks get many crucial wins when they were screwed? Especially in a league where Isaiah Thomas gets traded by the Celtics after what he did for them?
Yah, eff Melo. And yah, I can’t ever prove that what he did was 100% racist but the Asian American side of me has his suspicions.
Yeah this guy is definitely racist. FOH![]()
That contract was definitely ridiculous. And he was right. What is Lin doing in the NBA right now?![]()
You seem big mad that your boy Lin is a scrub and out of the NBA. Go root for him on whatever over seas team he’s on. Crying over Lin is like crying over Cole Aldrich. And mike D’anphony? Lmfao. Trash ass coach. That’s why he’s not a head coach anymore. Just like how ya mans Lin can’t get no contract by anyone. Meanwhile Melo breaking records till this day and just became a top 10 scorer of all time. I’m enjoying the tears!
Lin is out of the league, in part, because of racism. That's not really even controversial. Melo was part of that when he was here. Melo today may have grown from that, it was a decade ago or 25% of his lifetime ago. But no question if Lin was of a different background he'd have been a Knick longer.
Yuck.spree2kawhi wrote:What's that MPJ talk? For Randle? They could definitely use him, but they'd need to throw in more imo... I'd be interested.
Sexton, Frank/Quickley, RJ, MPJ, Mitch
Nice.
malik959 wrote:https://www.insider.com/knicks-point-guards-2010-where-are-they-now-2020-12#the-2017-18-season-was-jacks-last-in-the-nba-though-he-has-played-in-the-g-league-in-hopes-of-making-his-way-back-to-the-league-36
Oh the horror!
https://www.passionweiss.com/2018/09/25/a-definitive-ranking-of-22-years-of-new-york-knicks-point-guards/
ny-n-md wrote:nykballa2k4 wrote:3toheadmelo wrote:Yeah this guy is definitely racist. FOH![]()
That contract was definitely ridiculous. And he was right. What is Lin doing in the NBA right now?![]()
You seem big mad that your boy Lin is a scrub and out of the NBA. Go root for him on whatever over seas team he’s on. Crying over Lin is like crying over Cole Aldrich. And mike D’anphony? Lmfao. Trash ass coach. That’s why he’s not a head coach anymore. Just like how ya mans Lin can’t get no contract by anyone. Meanwhile Melo breaking records till this day and just became a top 10 scorer of all time. I’m enjoying the tears!
Lin is out of the league, in part, because of racism. That's not really even controversial. Melo was part of that when he was here. Melo today may have grown from that, it was a decade ago or 25% of his lifetime ago. But no question if Lin was of a different background he'd have been a Knick longer.
I’m not sure how you can say it’s because of racism he’s not in the league. There are several international players in the league. Maybe it’s because he’s not as good as he started off being? He can’t stay healthy? He’s high profile to an extant and not worth the drama?
Nazrmohamed wrote:ny-n-md wrote:nykballa2k4 wrote:
Lin is out of the league, in part, because of racism. That's not really even controversial. Melo was part of that when he was here. Melo today may have grown from that, it was a decade ago or 25% of his lifetime ago. But no question if Lin was of a different background he'd have been a Knick longer.
I’m not sure how you can say it’s because of racism he’s not in the league. There are several international players in the league. Maybe it’s because he’s not as good as he started off being? He can’t stay healthy? He’s high profile to an extant and not worth the drama?
Lin has to be the worst tear jerker I've ever seen. He's spent a long time cultivating this image and narrative that he's just the good little kid sleeping on Landry Fields couch. And if you don't want him on your team it's because you don't like Asians. Gimme a break. He lucked out because he joined a team who's coach was a pg centric coach who wanted to stick it to the star player the coach didn't want. Both in turn were dismissed and then the Knicks not only finished that current season with an 18&6 record without the both of them but the next season had the second beat record in the East. Good riddance.
ny-n-md wrote:Nazrmohamed wrote:ny-n-md wrote:I’m not sure how you can say it’s because of racism he’s not in the league. There are several international players in the league. Maybe it’s because he’s not as good as he started off being? He can’t stay healthy? He’s high profile to an extant and not worth the drama?
Lin has to be the worst tear jerker I've ever seen. He's spent a long time cultivating this image and narrative that he's just the good little kid sleeping on Landry Fields couch. And if you don't want him on your team it's because you don't like Asians. Gimme a break. He lucked out because he joined a team who's coach was a pg centric coach who wanted to stick it to the star player the coach didn't want. Both in turn were dismissed and then the Knicks not only finished that current season with an 18&6 record without the both of them but the next season had the second beat record in the East. Good riddance.
The worst part about the Lin experience was his stans. They made every message board unbearable! Lin could do no wrong. Melo is the problem. It became so divisive and toxic. I don’t miss it at all.


thebuzzardman wrote:Not a Sexton defense.
But this FO has been mostly willing to give Thibs the kind of players he likes.
Luckily, it's within reason and we heard of an instance of pushback (https://nypost.com/2021/03/09/how-leon-rose-rebuilt-the-knicks-an-inside-look/)
But, between Elf (Ugh) and Rose (Yay!) we can see what kind of PG Thibs has preference for.
Gets to the rim
Can organize the offense - to an extent. Floor maestro not necessary.
Looks to score
Some height
Tries on defense
SGA would seem to be the player that best fits that description. He's also not that available.
Sexton checks some boxes.
Anyway, we should all understand Thibs is going to push for another PG with those attributes because Rose can't really average more than 20 mpg, on the whole.
After that, it's about the various voices in the Knicks FO, where probably Ball has advocates, Sexton, Conley and Lowry. Maybe even CP3, and possibly Lillard, though I would think it would take the collective abilities of the FO braintrust to figure how to even make that happen, and then make a useful team happen after - not very likely, but that's my opinion.
Adelheid wrote:thebuzzardman wrote:Not a Sexton defense.
But this FO has been mostly willing to give Thibs the kind of players he likes.
Luckily, it's within reason and we heard of an instance of pushback (https://nypost.com/2021/03/09/how-leon-rose-rebuilt-the-knicks-an-inside-look/)
But, between Elf (Ugh) and Rose (Yay!) we can see what kind of PG Thibs has preference for.
Gets to the rim
Can organize the offense - to an extent. Floor maestro not necessary.
Looks to score
Some height
Tries on defense
SGA would seem to be the player that best fits that description. He's also not that available.
Sexton checks some boxes.
Anyway, we should all understand Thibs is going to push for another PG with those attributes because Rose can't really average more than 20 mpg, on the whole.
After that, it's about the various voices in the Knicks FO, where probably Ball has advocates, Sexton, Conley and Lowry. Maybe even CP3, and possibly Lillard, though I would think it would take the collective abilities of the FO braintrust to figure how to even make that happen, and then make a useful team happen after - not very likely, but that's my opinion.
I would also suggest Dejounte Murray (spurs) but afaik the price to acquire is largely unknown to the sporting public.
thebuzzardman wrote:Not a Sexton defense.
But this FO has been mostly willing to give Thibs the kind of players he likes.
Luckily, it's within reason and we heard of an instance of pushback (https://nypost.com/2021/03/09/how-leon-rose-rebuilt-the-knicks-an-inside-look/)
But, between Elf (Ugh) and Rose (Yay!) we can see what kind of PG Thibs has preference for.
Gets to the rim
Can organize the offense - to an extent. Floor maestro not necessary.
Looks to score
Some height
Tries on defense
SGA would seem to be the player that best fits that description. He's also not that available.
Sexton checks some boxes.
Anyway, we should all understand Thibs is going to push for another PG with those attributes because Rose can't really average more than 20 mpg, on the whole.
After that, it's about the various voices in the Knicks FO, where probably Ball has advocates, Sexton, Conley and Lowry. Maybe even CP3, and possibly Lillard, though I would think it would take the collective abilities of the FO braintrust to figure how to even make that happen, and then make a useful team happen after - not very likely, but that's my opinion.
KnixinSix wrote:thebuzzardman wrote:Not a Sexton defense.
But this FO has been mostly willing to give Thibs the kind of players he likes.
Luckily, it's within reason and we heard of an instance of pushback (https://nypost.com/2021/03/09/how-leon-rose-rebuilt-the-knicks-an-inside-look/)
But, between Elf (Ugh) and Rose (Yay!) we can see what kind of PG Thibs has preference for.
Gets to the rim
Can organize the offense - to an extent. Floor maestro not necessary.
Looks to score
Some height
Tries on defense
SGA would seem to be the player that best fits that description. He's also not that available.
Sexton checks some boxes.
Anyway, we should all understand Thibs is going to push for another PG with those attributes because Rose can't really average more than 20 mpg, on the whole.
After that, it's about the various voices in the Knicks FO, where probably Ball has advocates, Sexton, Conley and Lowry. Maybe even CP3, and possibly Lillard, though I would think it would take the collective abilities of the FO braintrust to figure how to even make that happen, and then make a useful team happen after - not very likely, but that's my opinion.
SGA is an incredible fit for what Thibs looks for. Lonzo is missing the shooting part but is a few rungs better than Payton in that department and has all the other ingredients.

thebuzzardman wrote:ny-n-md wrote:Nazrmohamed wrote:
Lin has to be the worst tear jerker I've ever seen. He's spent a long time cultivating this image and narrative that he's just the good little kid sleeping on Landry Fields couch. And if you don't want him on your team it's because you don't like Asians. Gimme a break. He lucked out because he joined a team who's coach was a pg centric coach who wanted to stick it to the star player the coach didn't want. Both in turn were dismissed and then the Knicks not only finished that current season with an 18&6 record without the both of them but the next season had the second beat record in the East. Good riddance.
The worst part about the Lin experience was his stans. They made every message board unbearable! Lin could do no wrong. Melo is the problem. It became so divisive and toxic. I don’t miss it at all.
Knicks should have built around Lin instead of Melo
ny-n-md wrote:thebuzzardman wrote:ny-n-md wrote:The worst part about the Lin experience was his stans. They made every message board unbearable! Lin could do no wrong. Melo is the problem. It became so divisive and toxic. I don’t miss it at all.
Knicks should have built around Lin instead of Melo
D’antoni’s teams always had inflated stats for his PG’s. How would that have worked out after we moved on from him? Lin stayed hurt and wasn’t nearly as productive as he was in that system apart from it. I’m good. Melo was the more proven player and it’s not close. Lin couldn’t even go left.
And for the record, I don’t really want to relive this debate.
