Ben Simmons trades go here (and here only): Expect warnings if not following forum rules

Moderators: HartfordWhalers, Texas Chuck, BullyKing, Andre Roberstan, loserX, Trader_Joe, Mamba4Goat, pacers33granger, MoneyTalks41890

Roy The Natural
RealGM
Posts: 10,302
And1: 5,450
Joined: Nov 07, 2014

Re: Ben Simmons trades go here (and here only): Expect warnings if not following forum rules 

Post#1221 » by Roy The Natural » Thu Sep 30, 2021 7:47 pm

doctor him wrote:
tidho wrote:
doctor him wrote:I don't think that changes a thing.

Simmons will get moved when a suitable offer comes in and not before.

No one is going to say "Oh well...I guess we need to take a role player and a late first type of offer now."

We all know where we're at and nothing's changed.


I think this is true. That doesn't mean things won't change though. As some point the team and Embiid specifically are going to get frustrated by this. At some point you're risking him wanting out if you just let the situation rot inside the organization.

Step 1 Simmons has to prove he's willing to give up money to stay away, but if he does then its the Sixers on the clock.


Anything "can" change in the future.

I do however enjoy the constant (and perhaps "hopeful") speculation from other fanbases that this scenario would spin into Embiid wanting out literally a month after signing his extension. (Should we speculate whether Durant is tired of Kyrie now too?).

Simmons wants to be dealt now, but that's not happening. He can pout or whatever, but the Sixers aren't going to take a bad deal. Moreover, the fanbase is fine with letting Simmons sit. He's the "bad guy" in this situation for leaking out the "fans" as one of his many, many, many excuses over the past couple of couple months.

If we get to the all-star break and the Sixers are in the 7th seed for example, then that might change, but that won't happen because:

1. Even without Simmons they are a 4 seed at worst.
2. Some other team with big dreams to make a playoff or make a playoff run (Portland, Sacramento, Minny, Cleveland, Chicago, etc...) is going to start out slow. Someone will talk themselves into paying close to market value for a 25 year old all star to sell their fanbase. A deal like that will buy an embattled GM another 12 -18 months.
3. Simmons (himself) isn't built to take the heat. Well before January, he's going to go to Klutch and tell them to make a deal happen. Rich P. will pull some off the books favor ("If you make this deal happen, then when _________ comes up as a free agent we'll make sure we don't forget your coming through for us here.")

But there's no pressure from the Sixers side on this until you start making reservations for Valentine's Day dinner.


I mean... I constantly hear this from 76ers fans. Some other team could start out slow and panic.... yet I never hear about the opposite. What if the 76ers start out slow and the distraction of Simmons mounts? I think it's a fool's errand to believe that there's any way that Simmons value goes up without getting on the court.

I think a trade for a guy like Lillard is probably long gone and out the window. Even if Lillard wants out, I don't think depressed value Simmons, some long away 1sts, and Maxey is the top deal coming Portland's way. Much like the Rockets, the disgruntled star trader is likely going to look in a different direction than a Simmons-centric trade.

I'm not going to sit here and say the 76ers must, or need, to trade Simmons. However, this naïve notion that this plan is without any real risk is utterly blind to reality. There is plenty of reason to think this goes nuclear and spirals as the season wears on. This whole ordeal feels like the 76ers are putting a large wad of cash on black at a roulette table with equal chances of winning a low gain trade, or crashing and burning into a trade in December they should've made at the beginning of the season, now with less picks and intrigue.

I understand the reasons for waiting for the 76ers. I'm not saying they shouldn't. But this isn't a CD ladder, this is gambling.
LAL1947
Assistant Coach
Posts: 4,383
And1: 2,621
Joined: Dec 28, 2018

Re: Ben Simmons trades go here (and here only): Expect warnings if not following forum rules 

Post#1222 » by LAL1947 » Thu Sep 30, 2021 7:49 pm

jbk1234 wrote:If you're going to take a hard line, if you're going to insist on a max return or nothing, you need to game out what that's likely to look like if things don't go your way. You can't engage in denialism.

Spoiler:
:dontknow:

Fair enough but there are some things you can't fully control... like a big mouth (Embiid)... and especially not if he's your best player.

And thanks! Not sure how I missed that smiley before. :thumbsup:
basketballwacko2
RealGM
Posts: 22,135
And1: 4,370
Joined: May 11, 2002
Location: Just outside of No where.
     

Re: Ben Simmons trades go here (and here only): Expect warnings if not following forum rules 

Post#1223 » by basketballwacko2 » Thu Sep 30, 2021 7:52 pm

Tomjas wrote:
Helsbyte wrote:
Tomjas wrote:
9th seed

There’s literally nobody on your roster not available for Simmons



Bwahahahaha!!!! 9th seed.....ROFL........ Indy was so decimated by Injuries that we were lucky to get that high. Sabonis was playing out of his mind as we were rolling out a lineup with him plus 4 guys from the G-League. Atleast Sabonis and Brogdon show up for work. Good luck with Simmons.


9th seed in the East

Just stop this nonsense

You might not like Simmons but he would drag your team into the playoffs every year


Good luck with your player who refuses to report to camp. I don't even want the guy a sf who can't shoot! :nonono:
basketballwacko2
RealGM
Posts: 22,135
And1: 4,370
Joined: May 11, 2002
Location: Just outside of No where.
     

Re: Ben Simmons trades go here (and here only): Expect warnings if not following forum rules 

Post#1224 » by basketballwacko2 » Thu Sep 30, 2021 7:56 pm

Lovetron Joe wrote:Brogdon shows up for work when healthy. Which is about 2/3 of the time.


I'll agree Brogdon does miss some games but he is reporting to camp and willing to play.
timeaftertime
Freshman
Posts: 71
And1: 45
Joined: Mar 01, 2021

Re: Ben Simmons trades go here (and here only): Expect warnings if not following forum rules 

Post#1225 » by timeaftertime » Thu Sep 30, 2021 8:21 pm

mademan wrote:
Read on Twitter


Didnt see this part. Embiid airing it out

Ooooof. I bet the Sixers aren't thrilled that Embiid is seemingly making it easier for Simmons to stay away, especially because I think Jimmy ultimately wanted to land in Miami anyway.

I think some of the trade packages here recently are starting to miss how Morey operates. It's not really Morey's usual gameplan to trade a player for the best player he can get, but rather for the most value he can get back. Morey has generally operated with two main goals, even dating back to his days in Houston. The primary goal is to get superstar players. The secondary goal is to get pieces that he can then turn into a superstar player. Almost every trade you look at for the last decade, dating back to the Harden trade, has followed that same formula. I don't really think Morey values a player like CJ McCollum, who is a good player but paid like a superstar, very highly because he takes up a max slot and the NBA is all about that top-line talent.

I think that's probably why the Timberwolves keep coming up and think they have a shot. That's also why the Wolves keep getting mentioned with a third team, but the same logic applies without a third team. If Morey can extract enough value from the Timberwolves, loading up the war-chest to take a run at an all-star that could potentially become available is more appealing to him than CJ on a max deal. The Timberwolves have $30 million in three expiring contracts (two of which could be rotation players on a playoff team) and their picks are generally the most valuable in the league. The Wolves also have young, cheap talent (McDaniels, Reid, Bolmaro, Vanderbilt, and Edwards (who I wouldn't expect the Wolves to trade)) that any rebuilding team would love to attempt to develop during a few seasons of tanking. Ultimately, it's going to be a lot easier for the Sixers to land an all-star with the Wolves assets (if they can get a favorable package) than it is with Simmons. The Sixers don't really need regular season help. They can sit on the Wolves assets for a couple months and still not be in danger of not making the playoffs, they just would need to be confident they could make a move before the deadline that would land them a superstar. If Simmons really is willing to sit out all season, that timeline to use the Wolves assets extends to the end of the season (because Simmons wouldn't be a factor for the Sixers this upcoming season anyway).
Roy The Natural
RealGM
Posts: 10,302
And1: 5,450
Joined: Nov 07, 2014

Re: Ben Simmons trades go here (and here only): Expect warnings if not following forum rules 

Post#1226 » by Roy The Natural » Thu Sep 30, 2021 8:29 pm

timeaftertime wrote:
mademan wrote:
Read on Twitter


Didnt see this part. Embiid airing it out

Ooooof. I bet the Sixers aren't thrilled that Embiid is seemingly making it easier for Simmons to stay away, especially because I think Jimmy ultimately wanted to land in Miami anyway.

I think some of the trade packages here recently are starting to miss how Morey operates. It's not really Morey's usual gameplan to trade a player for the best player he can get, but rather for the most value he can get back. Morey has generally operated with two main goals, even dating back to his days in Houston. The primary goal is to get superstar players. The secondary goal is to get pieces that he can then turn into a superstar player. Almost every trade you look at for the last decade, dating back to the Harden trade, has followed that same formula. I don't really think Morey values a player like CJ McCollum, who is a good player but paid like a superstar, very highly because he takes up a max slot and the NBA is all about that top-line talent.

I think that's probably why the Timberwolves keep coming up and think they have a shot. That's also why the Wolves keep getting mentioned with a third team, but the same logic applies without a third team. If Morey can extract enough value from the Timberwolves, loading up the war-chest to take a run at an all-star that could potentially become available is more appealing to him than CJ on a max deal. The Timberwolves have $30 million in three expiring contracts (two of which could be rotation players on a playoff team) and their picks are generally the most valuable in the league. The Wolves also have young, cheap talent (McDaniels, Reid, Bolmaro, Vanderbilt, and Edwards (who I wouldn't expect the Wolves to trade)) that any rebuilding team would love to attempt to develop during a few seasons of tanking. Ultimately, it's going to be a lot easier for the Sixers to land an all-star with the Wolves assets (if they can get a favorable package) than it is with Simmons. The Sixers don't really need regular season help. They can sit on the Wolves assets for a couple months and still not be in danger of not making the playoffs, they just would need to be confident they could make a move before the deadline that would land them a superstar. If Simmons really is willing to sit out all season, that timeline to use the Wolves assets extends to the end of the season (because Simmons wouldn't be a factor for the Sixers this upcoming season anyway).


Just for clarity, CJ does not take up a max slot and is not being paid like "a superstar."
User avatar
zimpy27
Forum Mod
Forum Mod
Posts: 45,784
And1: 44,041
Joined: Jul 13, 2014

Re: Ben Simmons trades go here (and here only): Expect warnings if not following forum rules 

Post#1227 » by zimpy27 » Thu Sep 30, 2021 8:40 pm

Yeah Embiid really hurting the package Philly gets back now.

He needs to hold his tongue until after the trade.
"Let's play some basketball!" - Fergie
User avatar
babyjax13
RealGM
Posts: 35,683
And1: 18,186
Joined: Jul 02, 2006
Location: Fresno, eating Birria
     

Re: Ben Simmons trades go here (and here only): Expect warnings if not following forum rules 

Post#1228 » by babyjax13 » Thu Sep 30, 2021 8:41 pm

Timberwolves trade: Taurean Prince, Patrick Beverley, Jaylen Nowell, Jaden McDaniels, Naz Reid, 2022 MIN 1st (unprotected), 2024 MIN 1st (unprotected), 2026 MIN 1st (unprotected)
76ers trade: Ben Simmons, Isaiah Joe, Paul Reed, Furkan Korkmaz, Andre Drummond

Minnesota gets a star player while keeping all of their starting 5 but McDaniels:
Towns/Drummond/Reed
Simmons/Vanderbilt/Layman
Edwards/Layman/Okogie
Beasley/Korkmaz/Joe
Russell/McLaughlin/Simmons

76ers build a warchest of prospects and picks to flip for a star player later in the season, while still having a good enough rotation to make the playoffs.

Embiid/Reid
Harris/Prince/Reid/Niang
McDaniels/Thybulle/Prince
Curry/Maxey/Nowell
Beverley/Milton/Springer

1st round picks:
2022: PHI, MIN
2023: PHI
2024: PHI, MIN
2025: PHI (if 1-6)
2026: PHI (if 1-4 and not conveyed in 2025), MIN
2027: PHI (if 1-4 and not conveyed in 2025, 2026)
Image

JazzMatt13 wrote:just because I think aliens probably have to do with JFK, doesn't mean my theory that Jazz will never get Wiggins, isn't true.

JColl
OutsidetheNBA
Senior
Posts: 657
And1: 382
Joined: Sep 15, 2020
 

Re: Ben Simmons trades go here (and here only): Expect warnings if not following forum rules 

Post#1229 » by OutsidetheNBA » Thu Sep 30, 2021 8:50 pm

Roy The Natural wrote:
doctor him wrote:
tidho wrote:
I think this is true. That doesn't mean things won't change though. As some point the team and Embiid specifically are going to get frustrated by this. At some point you're risking him wanting out if you just let the situation rot inside the organization.

Step 1 Simmons has to prove he's willing to give up money to stay away, but if he does then its the Sixers on the clock.


Anything "can" change in the future.

I do however enjoy the constant (and perhaps "hopeful") speculation from other fanbases that this scenario would spin into Embiid wanting out literally a month after signing his extension. (Should we speculate whether Durant is tired of Kyrie now too?).

Simmons wants to be dealt now, but that's not happening. He can pout or whatever, but the Sixers aren't going to take a bad deal. Moreover, the fanbase is fine with letting Simmons sit. He's the "bad guy" in this situation for leaking out the "fans" as one of his many, many, many excuses over the past couple of couple months.

If we get to the all-star break and the Sixers are in the 7th seed for example, then that might change, but that won't happen because:

1. Even without Simmons they are a 4 seed at worst.
2. Some other team with big dreams to make a playoff or make a playoff run (Portland, Sacramento, Minny, Cleveland, Chicago, etc...) is going to start out slow. Someone will talk themselves into paying close to market value for a 25 year old all star to sell their fanbase. A deal like that will buy an embattled GM another 12 -18 months.
3. Simmons (himself) isn't built to take the heat. Well before January, he's going to go to Klutch and tell them to make a deal happen. Rich P. will pull some off the books favor ("If you make this deal happen, then when _________ comes up as a free agent we'll make sure we don't forget your coming through for us here.")

But there's no pressure from the Sixers side on this until you start making reservations for Valentine's Day dinner.


I mean... I constantly hear this from 76ers fans. Some other team could start out slow and panic.... yet I never hear about the opposite. What if the 76ers start out slow and the distraction of Simmons mounts? I think it's a fool's errand to believe that there's any way that Simmons value goes up without getting on the court.

I think a trade for a guy like Lillard is probably long gone and out the window. Even if Lillard wants out, I don't think depressed value Simmons, some long away 1sts, and Maxey is the top deal coming Portland's way. Much like the Rockets, the disgruntled star trader is likely going to look in a different direction than a Simmons-centric trade.

I'm not going to sit here and say the 76ers must, or need, to trade Simmons. However, this naïve notion that this plan is without any real risk is utterly blind to reality. There is plenty of reason to think this goes nuclear and spirals as the season wears on. This whole ordeal feels like the 76ers are putting a large wad of cash on black at a roulette table with equal chances of winning a low gain trade, or crashing and burning into a trade in December they should've made at the beginning of the season, now with less picks and intrigue.

I understand the reasons for waiting for the 76ers. I'm not saying they shouldn't. But this isn't a CD ladder, this is gambling.


Yeah, I think 76ers fans are right that there is about a 0% chance Embiid asks out. At the same time, other fans are right that the 76ers' situation could get much worse if they have a bad start. More Embiid public comments, constant pressure from the media, other guys on the team getting discouraged b/c their names are in trade reports, just plain losing -- lots of bad could happen and the 76ers *could* find themselves with even less leverage.

Also, I absolutely agree with your point above in bold/underline. A lot of posters assume that if Beal or Lillard ask out, the 76ers will have the best shot at them. Why though?

Lillard is from the Bay area and might want to go to GS or NYC. GS can offer a much better rebuilding package than the 76ers. Or maybe the Blazers/Wizards would prefer a boatload of picks. Or maybe a better player than Simmons (like Jaylen Brown, or Jamal Murray, or RJ Barrett) would be available.

Of course Simmons++ for Beal or Lillard *could* happen, but it doesn't seem likely even if they do demand a trade.
Helsbyte
Pro Prospect
Posts: 910
And1: 515
Joined: Oct 23, 2020
       

Re: Ben Simmons trades go here (and here only): Expect warnings if not following forum rules 

Post#1230 » by Helsbyte » Thu Sep 30, 2021 8:52 pm

doctor him wrote:
Helsbyte wrote:
doctor him wrote:
Come on now...Let's be fair.

Using 2021 season (only) is a misrepresentation.

Going back to 2016-2017 Brogdon has played in (75, 48, 64, 54 and 56 games). You can count on his missing 20-25 games a year every year.

One of the main reasons why the Bucks let him go to Indy was his health.


Why did you only post Brogdon's last 5 years and not Simmons last 5 as comparison? Here let me.


Simmons Brogdon
2016 0 (missed season) 75
2017 81 48
2018 79 64
2019 57 54
2020 58 56

TOTALS 275 297


So over the span of both players career(5 years each) Brogdon has played in more games than Simmons and you would have us believe Brogdon is more injury prone of the two. Over the past 2 season there is only a 5 game difference between the 2. Maybe I am not the one cherry picking stats.......just saying.


Simmons broke a foot (rookies), had a knee (during the pandemic) and a back. Only the back injury would concern me as something chronic.

Brogdon is always hurt. Every season for the last 4 years and lots of different stuff. You want me to list them? Glad you asked.

DATE DESCRIPTION
04/29/2021 Hamstring
04/02/2021 Hip
03/22/2021 Back
02/27/2021 Knee
08/11/2020 Neck
08/05/2020 Neck
07/31/2020 Cervical Strain
03/04/2020 Hip
01/25/2020 Concussion
01/22/2020 Laceration
12/31/2019 Back
12/30/2019 Left Hamstring
12/23/2019 Groin
12/07/2019 Hand
11/15/2019 Back
03/15/2019 Heel
03/02/2019 Heel
02/22/2019 Foot
01/28/2019 Sternum
12/17/2018 Hamstring
12/14/2018 Hamstring
02/01/2018 Torn Left Quadricep Tendon
01/26/2018 Sore Right Calf
10/23/2017 Sprained Left Ankle


Yeah you win the research award. Congrats! I really don't care to look up Simmons missed games and why. All I know is you wanted to compare them over a 5 year period and Brogdon has been on the court more than Simmons during that time frame. Drops Mic!
doctor him
Assistant Coach
Posts: 4,309
And1: 434
Joined: Feb 06, 2008
         

Re: Ben Simmons trades go here (and here only): Expect warnings if not following forum rules 

Post#1231 » by doctor him » Thu Sep 30, 2021 9:19 pm

Roy The Natural wrote:
doctor him wrote:
tidho wrote:
I think this is true. That doesn't mean things won't change though. As some point the team and Embiid specifically are going to get frustrated by this. At some point you're risking him wanting out if you just let the situation rot inside the organization.

Step 1 Simmons has to prove he's willing to give up money to stay away, but if he does then its the Sixers on the clock.


Anything "can" change in the future.

I do however enjoy the constant (and perhaps "hopeful") speculation from other fanbases that this scenario would spin into Embiid wanting out literally a month after signing his extension. (Should we speculate whether Durant is tired of Kyrie now too?).

Simmons wants to be dealt now, but that's not happening. He can pout or whatever, but the Sixers aren't going to take a bad deal. Moreover, the fanbase is fine with letting Simmons sit. He's the "bad guy" in this situation for leaking out the "fans" as one of his many, many, many excuses over the past couple of couple months.

If we get to the all-star break and the Sixers are in the 7th seed for example, then that might change, but that won't happen because:

1. Even without Simmons they are a 4 seed at worst.
2. Some other team with big dreams to make a playoff or make a playoff run (Portland, Sacramento, Minny, Cleveland, Chicago, etc...) is going to start out slow. Someone will talk themselves into paying close to market value for a 25 year old all star to sell their fanbase. A deal like that will buy an embattled GM another 12 -18 months.
3. Simmons (himself) isn't built to take the heat. Well before January, he's going to go to Klutch and tell them to make a deal happen. Rich P. will pull some off the books favor ("If you make this deal happen, then when _________ comes up as a free agent we'll make sure we don't forget your coming through for us here.")

But there's no pressure from the Sixers side on this until you start making reservations for Valentine's Day dinner.


I mean... I constantly hear this from 76ers fans. Some other team could start out slow and panic.... yet I never hear about the opposite. What if the 76ers start out slow and the distraction of Simmons mounts? I think it's a fool's errand to believe that there's any way that Simmons value goes up without getting on the court.

I think a trade for a guy like Lillard is probably long gone and out the window. Even if Lillard wants out, I don't think depressed value Simmons, some long away 1sts, and Maxey is the top deal coming Portland's way. Much like the Rockets, the disgruntled star trader is likely going to look in a different direction than a Simmons-centric trade.

I'm not going to sit here and say the 76ers must, or need, to trade Simmons. However, this naïve notion that this plan is without any real risk is utterly blind to reality. There is plenty of reason to think this goes nuclear and spirals as the season wears on. This whole ordeal feels like the 76ers are putting a large wad of cash on black at a roulette table with equal chances of winning a low gain trade, or crashing and burning into a trade in December they should've made at the beginning of the season, now with less picks and intrigue.

I understand the reasons for waiting for the 76ers. I'm not saying they shouldn't. But this isn't a CD ladder, this is gambling.


Actually, I can guarantee that a couple of those teams WILL start out slow. I can't tell you what happens from there, but if some teams win then others will lose and those teams that I listed have plans that (IMHO) outstretch their current talent. All of them can't win the extra 10-15 games they need to meet their expectations.

And I'll repeat what I said above since you missed it:

"If we get to the all-star break and the Sixers are in the 7th seed for example, then that might change, but that won't happen because:

1. Even without Simmons they are a 4 seed at worst."

They'll miss Simmons defense for sure. They'll miss his playmaking and I think the offense is going to be more stagnant than people believe.

But the overall talent of Embiid is enough to carry them to a respectable seed virtually by himself. I expect improvement and real contributions from the young players (Maxey and Thybulle primarily and eventually Joe and Reed) so I can't picture a 1 seed dropping all that far even if Simmons stays home.
jbk1234
Retired Mod
Retired Mod
Posts: 59,402
And1: 36,391
Joined: Dec 22, 2010
 

Re: Ben Simmons trades go here (and here only): Expect warnings if not following forum rules 

Post#1232 » by jbk1234 » Thu Sep 30, 2021 9:25 pm

zimpy27 wrote:Yeah Embiid really hurting the package Philly gets back now.

He needs to hold his tongue until after the trade.


I don't think it hurts his trade value per se. The factors that are setting Ben's trade value are related to what he can, and cannot do, on the court. They're bigger than comments made by his teammates, Klutch, or even him holding out. Those factors may be stopping teams from adding an additional first just to get it done, but the delta between what the Sixers wanted, and what teams were willing to offer were basketball related.

What Biid's comments do is dash any hope that they could wait this out with Ben contributing this year. I think they were already at ghost of chance on that front anyway tbh. But it really makes Morey looks like he's a bit detached from reality when it comes to his plan of Ben rehabilitating his trade value on the court this season (and if we're being honest, that probably wasn't going to happen even if Ben reported). I'll just draw an inside straight and everything will break right isn't a plan, it's a prayer. The current outcome was not only perfectly foreseeable, but far more likely than any cheerful reunion. If Ben didn't report, and he repeatedly insisted he wouldn't, Embiid was eventually going to start popping off about it.
cbosh4mvp wrote:
Jarret Allen isn’t winning you anything. Garland won’t show up in the playoffs. Mobley is a glorified dunk man. Mitchell has some experience but is a liability on defense. To me, the Cavs are a treadmill team.
User avatar
Domejandro
Forum Mod - Timberwolves
Forum Mod - Timberwolves
Posts: 20,528
And1: 30,961
Joined: Jul 29, 2014

Re: Ben Simmons trades go here (and here only): Expect warnings if not following forum rules 

Post#1233 » by Domejandro » Thu Sep 30, 2021 9:32 pm

timeaftertime wrote:Ooooof. I bet the Sixers aren't thrilled that Embiid is seemingly making it easier for Simmons to stay away, especially because I think Jimmy ultimately wanted to land in Miami anyway.

Joel Embiid being upfront about how he feels changes absolutely nothing about the situation. It’s over, Ben Simmons is not playing for Philadelphia. Absolutely nothing is changing that.

I argue this on the Minnesota forum pretty consistently, nothing at this point is going to “kill Ben Simmons’ value” nor rehabilitate it. The situation functionally is what it is, at this point.
the_process
RealGM
Posts: 29,435
And1: 10,470
Joined: May 01, 2010

Re: Ben Simmons trades go here (and here only): Expect warnings if not following forum rules 

Post#1234 » by the_process » Thu Sep 30, 2021 9:41 pm

Texas Chuck wrote:
jbk1234 wrote:Morey didn't have a good hand here, but man, did he play it poorly.
Read on Twitter
?s=20

Sent from my SAMSUNG-SM-J327A using RealGM mobile app


Embiid saying this doesn't make it true. Butler wanted to sign with Miami, not Philly. This was not Philly saying we'd rather have Hoford than Butler.

I mean reality still has to matter here.


If the Sixers would have traded Simmons and fired Brett Brown, Jimmy would have re-signed.
User avatar
Lovetron Joe
Rookie
Posts: 1,157
And1: 488
Joined: Dec 26, 2014
       

Re: Ben Simmons trades go here (and here only): Expect warnings if not following forum rules 

Post#1235 » by Lovetron Joe » Thu Sep 30, 2021 9:42 pm

Ben's trade value will be based upon teams bidding against each other (which is already in progress). All of this Klutch propaganda will not erode his value or speed his exit from town. It may push other teams into the bidding (FOMO). Trade board posters that think their non-playoff teams 4th to 6th best player, filler and some late firsts will beat out other teams best offers will be disappointed. There are reasons that those teams have done poorly. Simmons can raise the floor of those teams, but only if they are the successful bidder.

Morey has the support of ownership and most of the local fanbase. He will wait as long as necessary for the best deal.
Pelon chingon
Lead Assistant
Posts: 4,970
And1: 6,627
Joined: Jan 07, 2018

Re: Ben Simmons trades go here (and here only): Expect warnings if not following forum rules 

Post#1236 » by Pelon chingon » Thu Sep 30, 2021 10:04 pm

Lovetron Joe wrote:Ben's trade value will be based upon teams bidding against each other (which is already in progress). All of this Klutch propaganda will not erode his value or speed his exit from town. It may push other teams into the bidding (FOMO). Trade board posters that think their non-playoff teams 4th to 6th best player, filler and some late firsts will beat out other teams best offers will be disappointed. There are reasons that those teams have done poorly. Simmons can raise the floor of those teams, but only if they are the successful bidder.

Morey has the support of ownership and most of the local fanbase. He will wait as long as necessary for the best deal.


Your excluding the part about bringing in Simmons being extremely risky for the teams with even faint interest in Him.
User avatar
zimpy27
Forum Mod
Forum Mod
Posts: 45,784
And1: 44,041
Joined: Jul 13, 2014

Re: Ben Simmons trades go here (and here only): Expect warnings if not following forum rules 

Post#1237 » by zimpy27 » Thu Sep 30, 2021 10:16 pm

jbk1234 wrote:
zimpy27 wrote:Yeah Embiid really hurting the package Philly gets back now.

He needs to hold his tongue until after the trade.


I don't think it hurts his trade value per se. The factors that are setting Ben's trade value are related to what he can, and cannot do, on the court. They're bigger than comments made by his teammates, Klutch, or even him holding out. Those factors may be stopping teams from adding an additional first just to get it done, but the delta between what the Sixers wanted, and what teams were willing to offer were basketball related.

What Biid's comments do is dash any hope that they could wait this out with Ben contributing this year. I think they were already at ghost of chance on that front anyway tbh. But it really makes Morey looks like he's a bit detached from reality when it comes to his plan of Ben rehabilitating his trade value on the court this season (and if we're being honest, that probably wasn't going to happen even if Ben reported). I'll just draw an inside straight and everything will break right isn't a plan, it's a prayer. The current outcome was not only perfectly foreseeable, but far more likely than any cheerful reunion. If Ben didn't report, and he repeatedly insisted he wouldn't, Embiid was eventually going to start popping off about it.


I kind of think it makes Ben look like a difficult player though. That's why I think it hurts trade value. Also makes it clear that Philly can't mend it with Ben, a narrative Philly are trying to push is that they can.
"Let's play some basketball!" - Fergie
SNPA
General Manager
Posts: 9,268
And1: 8,623
Joined: Apr 15, 2020

Re: Ben Simmons trades go here (and here only): Expect warnings if not following forum rules 

Post#1238 » by SNPA » Thu Sep 30, 2021 10:27 pm

Lovetron Joe wrote:Ben's trade value will be based upon teams bidding against each other (which is already in progress). All of this Klutch propaganda will not erode his value or speed his exit from town. It may push other teams into the bidding (FOMO). Trade board posters that think their non-playoff teams 4th to 6th best player, filler and some late firsts will beat out other teams best offers will be disappointed. There are reasons that those teams have done poorly. Simmons can raise the floor of those teams, but only if they are the successful bidder.

Morey has the support of ownership and most of the local fanbase. He will wait as long as necessary for the best deal.

How does Morey gain leverage letting this go into the season? He should have handled it already. Teams have likely made their offers and are sitting. Maybe one breaks and adds something of value but Morey likely has most of what he can get on the table and teams will wait till he breaks. Sure he’ll play a couple teams off each other at the very end, but teams know that have held what little sweetener they’d give. Morey isn’t in a strong position and it’s getting worse.
Roy The Natural
RealGM
Posts: 10,302
And1: 5,450
Joined: Nov 07, 2014

Re: Ben Simmons trades go here (and here only): Expect warnings if not following forum rules 

Post#1239 » by Roy The Natural » Thu Sep 30, 2021 10:29 pm

zimpy27 wrote:
jbk1234 wrote:
zimpy27 wrote:Yeah Embiid really hurting the package Philly gets back now.

He needs to hold his tongue until after the trade.


I don't think it hurts his trade value per se. The factors that are setting Ben's trade value are related to what he can, and cannot do, on the court. They're bigger than comments made by his teammates, Klutch, or even him holding out. Those factors may be stopping teams from adding an additional first just to get it done, but the delta between what the Sixers wanted, and what teams were willing to offer were basketball related.

What Biid's comments do is dash any hope that they could wait this out with Ben contributing this year. I think they were already at ghost of chance on that front anyway tbh. But it really makes Morey looks like he's a bit detached from reality when it comes to his plan of Ben rehabilitating his trade value on the court this season (and if we're being honest, that probably wasn't going to happen even if Ben reported). I'll just draw an inside straight and everything will break right isn't a plan, it's a prayer. The current outcome was not only perfectly foreseeable, but far more likely than any cheerful reunion. If Ben didn't report, and he repeatedly insisted he wouldn't, Embiid was eventually going to start popping off about it.


I kind of think it makes Ben look like a difficult player though. That's why I think it hurts trade value. Also makes it clear that Philly can't mend it with Ben, a narrative Philly are trying to push is that they can.


It's interesting because I really don't see any reason whatsoever for Ben's value to rise when he's not on the court. We haven't really heard anything outside Kyrie that sounds remotely close to what Morey reportedly wants. In the end, a Ben Simmons trade may be tied more to the play of Maxey and/or Thybulle and them proving to be enough to get the 76ers over the hump in trade conversations for a better player than Simmons.

I just don't see how you go from Brogdon and a 1st and offers like that to acquiring Beal for Simmons and picks/unspectacular prospects. There's an implicit notion that of a team plays poorly to start the year, then all of the sudden the play is to value a guy a ton more than you did 2 months ago. When he's not on the court to prove that you should. I just don't think it's a reality based belief.
sterncohen
Bench Warmer
Posts: 1,422
And1: 59
Joined: Oct 07, 2006

Re: Ben Simmons trades go here (and here only): Expect warnings if not following forum rules 

Post#1240 » by sterncohen » Thu Sep 30, 2021 10:29 pm

Sixers fan here. My view is that, regardless of whether Jimmy Butler in Philadelphia was ever a good idea or whether the Sixers could have kept him, Embiid basically told the truth. The Sixers have tried for years now to build a team that would work with Simmons' unusual mix of off-the-chart strengths and significant weaknesses. They didn't pull it off, and now it's somebody else's turn to do the same.

I agree with the posters who have said, basically, that nothing Embiid says can help or hurt Simmons' value much. There will be a deal whenever Morey gets something he thinks is worth taking. He seems to be prepared for the long game, even if that means Simmons sitting for months. And I think he will have enormous support here for taking that stance, both in the local press (predictably vicious towards Simmons) and among fans who do not want a bad deal and will, rightly or wrongly, derive some satisfaction from Simmons not getting paid.

Return to Trades and Transactions