Lunartic wrote:TheLand13 wrote:Lunartic wrote:Charles telling it like it is
All KD has to do is just play 75% of his ability and this series looks much different, even if he loses to a good Celtics team that's fine.
This trash version of KD makes people question his entire legacy.
Why does this have to be a case of Kevin Durant playing like trash? You're saying all he has to do is play 75% of his ability, how do you know that isn't already happening?
People do this all the time with star players and I don't understand why. They did the same thing with LeBron back in 2011, that he just choked and collapsed under pressure. Why does it always come down to that? Because the guy is so good that there's no possible way opposing teams can slow them down, let alone lock them down? That's a terrible mindset to have. How can you possibly expect to win anything if you're already giving up on the possibility of slowing down the opposing teams best player?
And it's even worse here because the performance in question couldn't be more obvious. Durant isn't playing any worse than he normally was. He's not out there missing open looks on a consistent basis. He's not a step slower than he used to be. His decision making isn't any worse than it is now (not saying he was ever bad in that regard, just trying to make a point). He's the same player that he was last year. The difference here is that an elite perimeter defender with the physical capabilities to guard Durant is actually taking on the challenge of defending him. And the results speak for themselves. And if Tatum isn't the one guarding him, he has Jaylen Brown, Marcus Smart (who just won DPOY) and now Rob Williams to deal with, as well as a few others.
In other words, this is not a trash version of KD. This is KD going up against a team we haven't seen in a while: one that is taking the art of defense very seriously again, has multiple versatile defensive wings capable of guarding a multitude of players, and is both well coached and well prepared for the challenge ahead of them.
We need to stop ignoring the greatness of other teams because it's more convenient to say "this star player is playing like ****". It not only discredits the work they are putting in, but it's completely ignoring what's happening on the basketball court and that just isn't okay.
Sample size.
KD has played for many years and has played against top tier defenders. He's a GOAT level scorer and he's barely even taking shots, he's losing the ball without even being pressured, he's being stripped, he's gunshy.
KD has scored on Iggy, Lebron, Tatum, Jaylen Brown, Marcus Smart, Tony Allen, Ron Arrest, Tim Duncan, the list is endless. He can score on anyone yet this series he's playing completely unlike himself.
That's not to say the Celtics aren't playing great defense on him and Kyrie, they are. Two things can be true at once.
Same for the Lebron situation, he was clearly mentally shook in 2011. The Mavs didn't lock him down, he refused to even put up shots. It was mental.
Unless KD has an undisclosed injury, a large part of this is mental unless you think KD normally takes 12 shots a game in the playoffs.
He barely took shots for one game, and the entire reason he did that was because he was having difficulty dealing with the Celtics defense so he attempted to get other teammates involved. He straight up stated that himself. He just had 20 free throws in game 2, so you can't say he wasn't attacking before game 3.
Yes, Durant has scored on those guys. But of those teams, how many of them had the amount of versatile defenders capable of giving Durant fits like the Celtics do? How many of them were as elite defensively as a team? And how many of those instances did Durant do that while playing with the current team that he has now? Things were much different with what he had surrounding him in OKC and GS. Teams had to plan differently. Hell, even that isn't entirely accurate. We saw the 73 win warriors have success limiting Durant and they, like the current Celtics, were a versatile team stockpiled with multiple elite defensive players. The Celtics clearly have a goal in mind here with this series. Let Smart and Tatum do their thing on Irving and Durant. If they try switching, let them, good luck with the alternatives. And it's working. There's a reason Brooklyn's role players are actually playing a lot better than anyone expected. They are not receiving nearly the same amount of attention and focus that Durant and Irving are. Apart from one great game from Irving where he was hitting just about everything he shot (except for when he was defended by Smart), they have both struggled immensely throughout this series.
And I simply refuse to believe that what happened to LeBron in 2011 was mental. Yeah, you could argue that on defense because he was just as awful at that end and LeBron when focused on that end isn't getting lit up by Jason Terry. But on offense? That Dallas Mavericks team was perfectly built to handle LeBron. Multiple defenders who were lengthy and clogged up driving lines, and to top it off, a truly elite rim protecting seven foot big in Tyson Chandler who is incredibly mobile locking down the paint. If LeBron's jumper was falling, it wouldn't be as big of an issue. But the simple fact of the matter is, LeBron's jumper wasn't finding the mark in that series so he was basically screwed at that end. I guess you could argue that part is mental, but that's pushing it imo.
Now yes, both instances can be true. A player can be struggling while the other team is playing great defense. That's totally fine. But if that's the case, then tell me what parts of Durant's game is he struggling with that he's normally a lot better with against any regular team? Tell me what he's doing differently here that he normally doesn't do against other teams that he dominates? At least with the LeBron example, you have the fact that LeBron's jump shot wasn't falling so that's a legitimate argument that can be made. If the evidence is there to suggest that Durant is playing a completely different kind of game in this series than what he usually does and that's a factor in his struggles from the field, then the point is legitimate and Durant is in fact not playing at 100% of his capabilities. But you'd have to prove that, without a doubt, it has nothing to do with the Celtics defense and how they're playing against him and that this is just a case of Durant not being there mentally. And as far as I'm concerned, based on what I've seen in these three games, there is nothing to suggest that is the case here. Durant's shots are being heavily contested, he's being met at the rim almost every time he attacks it, unless he is out by the logo he's not being given a chance to breath.
If I'm missing something here, please do point it out.