2025 NBA PLAYOFFS East Semifinals: #2 Boston Celtics vs #3 New York Knicks (NYK leads 1-0)

Moderators: Clav, Domejandro, ken6199, bisme37, Dirk, KingDavid, cupcakesnake, bwgood77, zimpy27, infinite11285

Who wins and goes to the ECFs?

Poll ended at Thu May 8, 2025 2:36 am

Celtics in 4
27
10%
Celtics in 5
111
42%
Celtics in 6
58
22%
Celtics in 7
12
4%
Knicks in 4
9
3%
Knicks in 5
5
2%
Knicks in 6
15
6%
Knicks in 7
30
11%
 
Total votes: 267

ArksNetsSince99
General Manager
Posts: 7,729
And1: 6,924
Joined: Apr 10, 2021
 

Re: 2025 NBA PLAYOFFS East Semifinals: #2 Boston Celtics vs #3 New York Knicks 

Post#1741 » by ArksNetsSince99 » Wed May 7, 2025 3:52 am

LFGK wrote:
ArksNetsSince99 wrote:
NoStatsGuy wrote:
Is that even a shot at knicks fans? Losing meaningful games hurts and the knicks have a lot of fans. I understand meaningful games and lots of fans are both things, that dont apply to the nets. So you might think that was a bar. But it really wasnt :D


I need someone to translate this to English


I'll translate ....Nets suck :lol:


:lol: :lol: :lol: This was funny tbh
ArksNetsSince99
General Manager
Posts: 7,729
And1: 6,924
Joined: Apr 10, 2021
 

Re: 2025 NBA PLAYOFFS East Semifinals: #2 Boston Celtics vs #3 New York Knicks 

Post#1742 » by ArksNetsSince99 » Wed May 7, 2025 3:58 am

RHODEY wrote:
ArksNetsSince99 wrote:
RHODEY wrote:
Read on Twitter


Let’s be honest here

Molly isn’t the brightest light bulb in this room :lol: :lol: :lol:


Glad you decided to come out of your hidey hole to face the music.


Rhodey let’s make one thing clear , after you eliminated you don’t come near Barclays with Mikal at 4am asking for reimbursement :lol:

Deal is done , Mikal is all yours
doogie_hauser
Head Coach
Posts: 6,084
And1: 7,242
Joined: Feb 04, 2024
         

Re: 2025 NBA PLAYOFFS East Semifinals: #2 Boston Celtics vs #3 New York Knicks 

Post#1743 » by doogie_hauser » Wed May 7, 2025 4:02 am

cgf wrote:
doogie_hauser wrote:Jaylen Brown shouldn't play game 2. He is not fit/healthy


Do you guys have the depth to do that? What would your rotation look like with no Brown or Hauser (with or without KP)? Hopefully he's good to go moving forward, because whether we win or lose I want to see what this team looks like at its best against the best.


Rookie Baylor Schierman is worth a punt imo.
LFGK
Sixth Man
Posts: 1,840
And1: 1,479
Joined: Apr 24, 2024
       

Re: 2025 NBA PLAYOFFS East Semifinals: #2 Boston Celtics vs #3 New York Knicks 

Post#1744 » by LFGK » Wed May 7, 2025 5:20 am

doogie_hauser wrote:
cgf wrote:
doogie_hauser wrote:Jaylen Brown shouldn't play game 2. He is not fit/healthy


Do you guys have the depth to do that? What would your rotation look like with no Brown or Hauser (with or without KP)? Hopefully he's good to go moving forward, because whether we win or lose I want to see what this team looks like at its best against the best.


Rookie Baylor Schierman is worth a punt imo.



Ahh DOOGIE Hauser, another Celtic that had the Knicks as a joke this series...That rookie isn't getting any burn this series, may be a rotational player when they ship the 7 foot pansy though
megarover
Senior
Posts: 707
And1: 113
Joined: Aug 28, 2009
Location: NY to ATL and vice versa

Re: 2025 NBA PLAYOFFS East Semifinals: #2 Boston Celtics vs #3 New York Knicks (NYK leads 1-0) 

Post#1745 » by megarover » Wed May 7, 2025 6:14 am

Love to see them get this win when most were expecting a sweep.
User avatar
RHODEY
RealGM
Posts: 25,118
And1: 22,670
Joined: May 18, 2007
Location: Straight out of a comic book

Re: 2025 NBA PLAYOFFS East Semifinals: #2 Boston Celtics vs #3 New York Knicks 

Post#1746 » by RHODEY » Wed May 7, 2025 7:56 am

ArksNetsSince99 wrote:
RHODEY wrote:
ArksNetsSince99 wrote:
Let’s be honest here

Molly isn’t the brightest light bulb in this room :lol: :lol: :lol:


Glad you decided to come out of your hidey hole to face the music.


Rhodey let’s make one thing clear , after you eliminated you don’t come near Barclays with Mikal at 4am asking for reimbursement :lol:

Deal is done , Mikal is all yours

Right we are happy with his amazing defensive performance versus the Celtics...good luck with those crappy picks :lol:
FlatearthZorro
RealGM
Posts: 20,586
And1: 12,327
Joined: Feb 12, 2010
Location: Somewhere in Boston
     

Re: 2025 NBA PLAYOFFS East Semifinals: #2 Boston Celtics vs #3 New York Knicks 

Post#1747 » by FlatearthZorro » Wed May 7, 2025 8:51 am

LFGK wrote:
doogie_hauser wrote:
cgf wrote:
Do you guys have the depth to do that? What would your rotation look like with no Brown or Hauser (with or without KP)? Hopefully he's good to go moving forward, because whether we win or lose I want to see what this team looks like at its best against the best.


Rookie Baylor Schierman is worth a punt imo.



Ahh DOOGIE Hauser, another Celtic that had the Knicks as a joke this series...That rookie isn't getting any burn this series, may be a rotational player when they ship the 7 foot pansy though


Every stat and nearly every game suggested that, after losing 4 in the regular season and Boston having better players and stats in pretty much everything, did you expect him to pick the Knicks in 4-5?
Good assessment:

PLO wrote:Tatum played OK - took advantage of a few mismatches - decent on the defensive end. He is what we thought he was going into the season - a technically very proficient player operating close to his career ceiling as a rookie.
AussieCeltic
RealGM
Posts: 13,019
And1: 24,233
Joined: Jan 02, 2014
 

Re: 2025 NBA PLAYOFFS East Semifinals: #2 Boston Celtics vs #3 New York Knicks (NYK leads 1-0) 

Post#1748 » by AussieCeltic » Wed May 7, 2025 9:33 am

Read on Twitter
?s=46
LaLover11 wrote:I bet you $100 Mavs beat the Celtics
knicksfan974
Lead Assistant
Posts: 4,870
And1: 1,557
Joined: Mar 02, 2002
 

Re: 2025 NBA PLAYOFFS East Semifinals: #2 Boston Celtics vs #3 New York Knicks (NYK leads 1-0) 

Post#1749 » by knicksfan974 » Wed May 7, 2025 10:20 am

Time to shock the league again and take a commanding 2-0 series lead. Let's go Knicks!
cgf
RealGM
Posts: 35,090
And1: 14,457
Joined: Jul 01, 2008
   

Re: 2025 NBA PLAYOFFS East Semifinals: #2 Boston Celtics vs #3 New York Knicks 

Post#1750 » by cgf » Wed May 7, 2025 10:57 am

FlatearthZorro wrote:
LFGK wrote:
doogie_hauser wrote:
Rookie Baylor Schierman is worth a punt imo.



Ahh DOOGIE Hauser, another Celtic that had the Knicks as a joke this series...That rookie isn't getting any burn this series, may be a rotational player when they ship the 7 foot pansy though


Every stat and nearly every game suggested that, after losing 4 in the regular season and Boston having better players and stats in pretty much everything, did you expect him to pick the Knicks in 4-5?


At this point, we should know that the regular season is not the postseason...though the first two games went very differently from the latter two...and who has the better players is very much debatable :dontknow:
Capn'O wrote:We're the recovering meth addict older brother. And we've been clean for a few years now, thank you very much. Very uncouth to bring it up.

Brunson: So what are you paid to do?
Hart: Run around like an idiot during the game and f*** s*** up!
NiceLikeChrist
Sixth Man
Posts: 1,771
And1: 1,745
Joined: Mar 16, 2012
 

Re: 2025 NBA PLAYOFFS East Semifinals: #2 Boston Celtics vs #3 New York Knicks (NYK leads 1-0) 

Post#1751 » by NiceLikeChrist » Wed May 7, 2025 11:45 am

AussieCeltic wrote:
Read on Twitter
?s=46

Check last playoffs. Same thing happened. Their shooting only gets worse as the playoffs continue. In every series of the playoffs they shot worse than the series prior.

They just lucked out playing against injured teams and the pacers/Mavs. Neither of which should’ve been in the positions they were in.
NiceLikeChrist wrote:We are going to deeply regret this. We traded away the best player in the trade and still had to give up a great role player AND a pick?

so many people are going to eat their words about randle
FlatearthZorro
RealGM
Posts: 20,586
And1: 12,327
Joined: Feb 12, 2010
Location: Somewhere in Boston
     

Re: 2025 NBA PLAYOFFS East Semifinals: #2 Boston Celtics vs #3 New York Knicks 

Post#1752 » by FlatearthZorro » Wed May 7, 2025 12:06 pm

cgf wrote:
FlatearthZorro wrote:
LFGK wrote:

Ahh DOOGIE Hauser, another Celtic that had the Knicks as a joke this series...That rookie isn't getting any burn this series, may be a rotational player when they ship the 7 foot pansy though


Every stat and nearly every game suggested that, after losing 4 in the regular season and Boston having better players and stats in pretty much everything, did you expect him to pick the Knicks in 4-5?


At this point, we should know that the regular season is not the postseason though the first two games went very differently from the latter two...and who has the better players is very much debatable :dontknow:


Is it? You’re telling me the Knicks have a better roster?
At this point I think you’re mistaking personal biases with logic, there’s absolutely nothing suggesting the Knicks have the better team or has been the better team in the past I’d say 3-4 years.
Good assessment:

PLO wrote:Tatum played OK - took advantage of a few mismatches - decent on the defensive end. He is what we thought he was going into the season - a technically very proficient player operating close to his career ceiling as a rookie.
User avatar
Froob
Forum Mod - Celtics
Forum Mod - Celtics
Posts: 43,326
And1: 61,643
Joined: Nov 04, 2010
Location: ▼VII▲VIII
         

Re: 2025 NBA PLAYOFFS East Semifinals: #2 Boston Celtics vs #3 New York Knicks (NYK leads 1-0) 

Post#1753 » by Froob » Wed May 7, 2025 12:08 pm

Backs to wall. Let's go baby
Image

Tommy Heinsohn wrote:The game is not over until they look you in the face and start crying.


RIP The_Hater
Moose
Analyst
Posts: 3,733
And1: 1,676
Joined: Feb 20, 2002

Re: 2025 NBA PLAYOFFS East Semifinals: #2 Boston Celtics vs #3 New York Knicks 

Post#1754 » by Moose » Wed May 7, 2025 12:21 pm

FlatearthZorro wrote:
cgf wrote:
FlatearthZorro wrote:
Every stat and nearly every game suggested that, after losing 4 in the regular season and Boston having better players and stats in pretty much everything, did you expect him to pick the Knicks in 4-5?


At this point, we should know that the regular season is not the postseason though the first two games went very differently from the latter two...and who has the better players is very much debatable :dontknow:


Is it? You’re telling me the Knicks have a better roster?
At this point I think you’re mistaking personal biases with logic, there’s absolutely nothing suggesting the Knicks have the better team or has been the better team in the past I’d say 3-4 years.


The Celtics are the better team. A tough Game 1 win doesn't change that imo.

The Knicks are like Rocky when they opened up Drago with a hook. We'll see if they end up pulling off the upset.

In either case, if the Knicks can push this to 6 or 7, I would say that's admirable. And if they win the series, that's remarkable.
cgf
RealGM
Posts: 35,090
And1: 14,457
Joined: Jul 01, 2008
   

Re: 2025 NBA PLAYOFFS East Semifinals: #2 Boston Celtics vs #3 New York Knicks 

Post#1755 » by cgf » Wed May 7, 2025 12:33 pm

FlatearthZorro wrote:
cgf wrote:
FlatearthZorro wrote:
Every stat and nearly every game suggested that, after losing 4 in the regular season and Boston having better players and stats in pretty much everything, did you expect him to pick the Knicks in 4-5?


At this point, we should know that the regular season is not the postseason though the first two games went very differently from the latter two...and who has the better players is very much debatable :dontknow:


Is it? You’re telling me the Knicks have a better roster?
At this point I think you’re mistaking personal biases with logic, there’s absolutely nothing suggesting the Knicks have the better team or has been the better team in the past I’d say 3-4 years.


Who has the better team and better players are different conversations. You've clearly been the better team this season, but you've also had years to develop chemistry & figure out what works with this core, building up your depth around them & tweaking around the edges of the rotation. Our group not only has yet to have a training camp together, but its defensive anchor just got into game shape a month or so ago.

And against an exceptional team like yours, that lack of chemistry...especially defensively...can be a killer. In particular earlier in the season and if the coach of the less blooded-in underdog is keeping things basic for the regular season, before starting to get more aggressive with his defensive personnel for the postseason; as we've seen Thibs do with Anunoby & Bridges.


Plus, your roster being better on the whole doesn't mean we don't have our advantages. Like we have the best crunchtime creator in this series, and the defenders we have to throw at your ace match up better than the defenders you have to throw at ours. Similarly, when he's cooking, Towns is a weapon you guys just don't have because KP can't create for himself like Karl can, and he's just too soft around the rim.

Of course Karl can't protect the rim like KP, Jrue is a more credible shooter than Hart, Pritchard is having a way better season than McBride off the bench, Brunson is the biggest defensive weakness in either starting 5, etc...but like I said, your roster being better on the whole wouldn't mean we didn't have some advantages and you being the better team for the past however many years (including this one) doesn't necessarily mean you've got the better players or roster on the whole.


Not even getting into the Form vs Class question. As things are coming together for us to play our best basketball right now...finally got our top 7 healthy on the eve of the postseason; we've had the season for most of the guys to gel; OG & Bridges really stepped up when Brunson went down and have been playing their best basketball since, with OG leveling up as a ballhandler / self-creator; Towns started to figure out how to kill teams even when they stick a big wing on him & let their rim protector help on his drives; Thibs starting to get a lot more creative with our defensive schemes than he was in the regular season

...so even if one does think you outclass us across the board, we could beat you just on form.
Capn'O wrote:We're the recovering meth addict older brother. And we've been clean for a few years now, thank you very much. Very uncouth to bring it up.

Brunson: So what are you paid to do?
Hart: Run around like an idiot during the game and f*** s*** up!
User avatar
NoStatsGuy
Assistant Coach
Posts: 4,111
And1: 2,297
Joined: Feb 14, 2010
Location: Germany
 

Re: 2025 NBA PLAYOFFS East Semifinals: #2 Boston Celtics vs #3 New York Knicks 

Post#1756 » by NoStatsGuy » Wed May 7, 2025 12:39 pm

FlatearthZorro wrote:
cgf wrote:
FlatearthZorro wrote:
Every stat and nearly every game suggested that, after losing 4 in the regular season and Boston having better players and stats in pretty much everything, did you expect him to pick the Knicks in 4-5?


At this point, we should know that the regular season is not the postseason though the first two games went very differently from the latter two...and who has the better players is very much debatable :dontknow:


Is it? You’re telling me the Knicks have a better roster?
At this point I think you’re mistaking personal biases with logic, there’s absolutely nothing suggesting the Knicks have the better team or has been the better team in the past I’d say 3-4 years.


the starting 5 is pretty even to be fair. i think most reasonable fans would agree.

tatum and brown are a tad better than brunson, KAT.

and OG, Mikal, josh are a tad better or at least even with KP, white and jrue. i think its a pretty objective take.

my subjective take honestly is that brunson is the best player in the series. i know, i know... defense, versatility, etc. goes to tatum. but i think the way brunson closes games and the type of leader he is puts him ahead of tatum, if you ask me. i want brunson over tatum on my team at least.

to me its brunson, tatum, brown then kat. And OG is pretty close to KAT. And i know most wont agree with it, but thats fine. i firmly believe brunsons intangibles are by far the best and put him atop the list.

and now considering that houser, KP and brown are banged up/ill/injured i think its definitley a debate to be had, which team has more talent. The benefit the celtics have is, that they have won a ring together, played together for much longer and they execute better.

and yes you are definitley correct, the last couple years boston clearly had the better roster. but i think this year we are right up there, in terrms of talent at least. And this is the 1st year they play together. the celtics are not better because they have the better roster, the celtics are better because they execute way better on offense and thats coaching, experience and chemistry aswell.
im bout dat action boss
ArksNetsSince99
General Manager
Posts: 7,729
And1: 6,924
Joined: Apr 10, 2021
 

Re: 2025 NBA PLAYOFFS East Semifinals: #2 Boston Celtics vs #3 New York Knicks 

Post#1757 » by ArksNetsSince99 » Wed May 7, 2025 12:43 pm

NoStatsGuy wrote:
FlatearthZorro wrote:
cgf wrote:
At this point, we should know that the regular season is not the postseason though the first two games went very differently from the latter two...and who has the better players is very much debatable :dontknow:


Is it? You’re telling me the Knicks have a better roster?
At this point I think you’re mistaking personal biases with logic, there’s absolutely nothing suggesting the Knicks have the better team or has been the better team in the past I’d say 3-4 years.


the starting 5 is pretty even to be fair. i think most reasonable fans would agree.

tatum and brown are a tad better than brunson, KAT.

and OG, Mikal, josh are a tad better or at least even with KP, white and jrue. i think its a pretty objective take.

my subjective take honestly is that brunson is the best player in the series. i know, i know... defense, versatility, etc. goes to tatum. but i think the way brunson closes games and the type of leader he is puts him ahead of tatum, if you ask me. i want brunson over tatum on my team at least.

to me its brunson, tatum, brown then kat. And OG is pretty close to KAT. And i know most wont agree with it, but thats fine. i firmly believe brunsons intangibles are by far the best and put him atop the list.

and now considering that houser, KP and brown are banged up/ill/injured i think its definitley a debate to be had, which team has more talent. The benefit the celtics have is, that they have won a ring together, played together for much longer and they execute better.

and yes you are definitley correct, the last couple years boston clearly had the better roster. but i think this year we are right up there, in terrms of talent at least. And this is the 1st year they play together. the celtics are not better because they have the better roster, the celtics are better because they execute way better on offense and thats coaching, experience and chemistry aswell.


LOL
cgf
RealGM
Posts: 35,090
And1: 14,457
Joined: Jul 01, 2008
   

Re: 2025 NBA PLAYOFFS East Semifinals: #2 Boston Celtics vs #3 New York Knicks 

Post#1758 » by cgf » Wed May 7, 2025 12:48 pm

ArksNetsSince99 wrote:
NoStatsGuy wrote:
FlatearthZorro wrote:
Is it? You’re telling me the Knicks have a better roster?
At this point I think you’re mistaking personal biases with logic, there’s absolutely nothing suggesting the Knicks have the better team or has been the better team in the past I’d say 3-4 years.


the starting 5 is pretty even to be fair. i think most reasonable fans would agree.

tatum and brown are a tad better than brunson, KAT.

and OG, Mikal, josh are a tad better or at least even with KP, white and jrue. i think its a pretty objective take.

my subjective take honestly is that brunson is the best player in the series. i know, i know... defense, versatility, etc. goes to tatum. but i think the way brunson closes games and the type of leader he is puts him ahead of tatum, if you ask me. i want brunson over tatum on my team at least.

to me its brunson, tatum, brown then kat. And OG is pretty close to KAT. And i know most wont agree with it, but thats fine. i firmly believe brunsons intangibles are by far the best and put him atop the list.

and now considering that houser, KP and brown are banged up/ill/injured i think its definitley a debate to be had, which team has more talent. The benefit the celtics have is, that they have won a ring together, played together for much longer and they execute better.

and yes you are definitley correct, the last couple years boston clearly had the better roster. but i think this year we are right up there, in terrms of talent at least. And this is the 1st year they play together. the celtics are not better because they have the better roster, the celtics are better because they execute way better on offense and thats coaching, experience and chemistry aswell.


LOL


Plus we've got the better talisman. Nobody is stopping New York with our good luck charm leading us to the promised land!
Capn'O wrote:We're the recovering meth addict older brother. And we've been clean for a few years now, thank you very much. Very uncouth to bring it up.

Brunson: So what are you paid to do?
Hart: Run around like an idiot during the game and f*** s*** up!
ArksNetsSince99
General Manager
Posts: 7,729
And1: 6,924
Joined: Apr 10, 2021
 

Re: 2025 NBA PLAYOFFS East Semifinals: #2 Boston Celtics vs #3 New York Knicks 

Post#1759 » by ArksNetsSince99 » Wed May 7, 2025 12:51 pm

cgf wrote:
FlatearthZorro wrote:
cgf wrote:
At this point, we should know that the regular season is not the postseason though the first two games went very differently from the latter two...and who has the better players is very much debatable :dontknow:


Is it? You’re telling me the Knicks have a better roster?
At this point I think you’re mistaking personal biases with logic, there’s absolutely nothing suggesting the Knicks have the better team or has been the better team in the past I’d say 3-4 years.


Who has the better team and better players are different conversations. You've clearly been the better team this season, but you've also had years to develop chemistry & figure out what works with this core, building up your depth around them & tweaking around the edges of the rotation. Our group not only has yet to have a training camp together, but its defensive anchor just got into game shape a month or so ago.

And against an exceptional team like yours, that lack of chemistry...especially defensively...can be a killer. In particular earlier in the season and if the coach of the less blooded-in underdog is keeping things basic for the regular season, before starting to get more aggressive with his defensive personnel for the postseason; as we've seen Thibs do with Anunoby & Bridges.


Plus, your roster being better on the whole doesn't mean we don't have our advantages. Like we have the best crunchtime creator in this series, and the defenders we have to throw at your ace match up better than the defenders you have to throw at ours. Similarly, when he's cooking, Towns is a weapon you guys just don't have because KP can't create for himself like Karl can, and he's just too soft around the rim.

Of course Karl can't protect the rim like KP, Jrue is a more credible shooter than Hart, Pritchard is having a way better season than McBride off the bench, etc. but like I said, your roster being better on the whole wouldn't mean we didn't have some advantages and you being the better team this year doesn't necessarily mean you've got the better players or roster on the whole.


Not even getting into the Form vs Class question. As things are coming together for us to play our best basketball right now, so even if one does think you outclass us across the board, we could beat you just on form.


Rude awakening will come tonight

Then seeing the reality

Then panic

Then cries and teeth grinding

Then it will be 1-4 and Knicks fans will be back to blaming Thibs and Mikal for this world disaster

Let’s Go Celtics , in Leprechaun we trust
cgf
RealGM
Posts: 35,090
And1: 14,457
Joined: Jul 01, 2008
   

Re: 2025 NBA PLAYOFFS East Semifinals: #2 Boston Celtics vs #3 New York Knicks (NYK leads 1-0) 

Post#1760 » by cgf » Wed May 7, 2025 12:55 pm

donkki wrote:Time to shock the league again and take a commanding 2-0 series lead. Let's go Knicks!


I expect Boston to throw their best punch in this one. If that isn't enough for them to blow us out again, I'm going to start feeling really good about our chances of pulling this thing off. But I'm going into this one prepared to lose in convincing fashion, so they can reclaim some pride before this thing heads to the Garden and we can give them our best punch.
Capn'O wrote:We're the recovering meth addict older brother. And we've been clean for a few years now, thank you very much. Very uncouth to bring it up.

Brunson: So what are you paid to do?
Hart: Run around like an idiot during the game and f*** s*** up!

Return to The General Board