Jerry West or Larry Bird
Moderators: PaulieWal, Doctor MJ, Clyde Frazier, penbeast0, trex_8063
Jerry West or Larry Bird
- AmusingFiddle
- Rookie
- Posts: 1,092
- And1: 315
- Joined: Jun 17, 2008
Jerry West or Larry Bird
I grew up in the Larry Bird era and found him to be an absolute beast and merciless assassin on the court. The guy was a warrior and played thru many injuries while leading his team to championships.
Jerry West on the other had I have not watch play. The clips that I have seen of him, he seems very fluid almost timid. Comparatively, His numbers from what I understand are very impressive. Obviously he is the logo and one of the greatest ever for a reason.
Can any of you basketball savants shed some light on how you would compare the two and whom would you consider a better ball player?
Sent from my iPhone using RealGM mobile app
Jerry West on the other had I have not watch play. The clips that I have seen of him, he seems very fluid almost timid. Comparatively, His numbers from what I understand are very impressive. Obviously he is the logo and one of the greatest ever for a reason.
Can any of you basketball savants shed some light on how you would compare the two and whom would you consider a better ball player?
Sent from my iPhone using RealGM mobile app
Re: Jerry West or Larry Bird
-
- Lead Assistant
- Posts: 4,729
- And1: 4,909
- Joined: Feb 18, 2012
Re: Jerry West or Larry Bird
i'm not a savant, so all i got is one played pg/sg and other sf/pf and in different eras. so not exactly apples to apples. but bird is better.
screw these absolute garbage refs
Re: Jerry West or Larry Bird
-
- RealGM
- Posts: 13,327
- And1: 1,099
- Joined: Dec 13, 2003
- Location: Surprise AZ
- Contact:
Re: Jerry West or Larry Bird
Imagine if Kobe were a better shooter, rebounder, defender and passer and that is Jerry West.
HomoSapien wrote:Warspite, the greatest poster in the history of realgm.
Re: Jerry West or Larry Bird
-
- General Manager
- Posts: 8,086
- And1: 7,764
- Joined: Nov 08, 2009
Re: Jerry West or Larry Bird
Warspite wrote:Imagine if Kobe were a better shooter, rebounder, defender and passer and that is Jerry West.
I was going to say that this is stupid, but then I went to look at the stats and... well maybe.
Kobe 25ppg, 4.7 asts, 5.1rbds. TS% .550, WS/48 .170
West 27ppg, 6.7asts, 5.8 rbds, TS% .550, WS/48 .213
Re: Jerry West or Larry Bird
- bwgood77
- Global Mod
- Posts: 93,864
- And1: 57,569
- Joined: Feb 06, 2009
- Location: Austin
- Contact:
Re: Jerry West or Larry Bird
AmusingFiddle wrote:I grew up in the Larry Bird era and found him to be an absolute beast and merciless assassin on the court. The guy was a warrior and played thru many injuries while leading his team to championships.
Jerry West on the other had I have not watch play. The clips that I have seen of him, he seems very fluid almost timid. Comparatively, His numbers from what I understand are very impressive. Obviously he is the logo and one of the greatest ever for a reason.
Can any of you basketball savants shed some light on how you would compare the two and whom would you consider a better ball player?
Sent from my iPhone using RealGM mobile app
Threads of this nature are better served on the Player Comparisons forum.
Re: Jerry West or Larry Bird
-
- RealGM
- Posts: 60,452
- And1: 5,321
- Joined: Jul 12, 2006
- Location: HCA (Homecourt Advantage)
Re: Jerry West or Larry Bird
leolozon wrote:Warspite wrote:Imagine if Kobe were a better shooter, rebounder, defender and passer and that is Jerry West.
I was going to say that this is stupid, but then I went to look at the stats and... well maybe.
Kobe 25ppg, 4.7 asts, 5.1rbds. TS% .550, WS/48 .170
West 27ppg, 6.7asts, 5.8 rbds, TS% .550, WS/48 .213
That includes Kobe's first two seasons as well.
"Talent wins games, but teamwork and intelligence wins championships."
- Michael Jordan
Re: Jerry West or Larry Bird
-
- Assistant Coach
- Posts: 3,915
- And1: 726
- Joined: Jun 28, 2016
Re: Jerry West or Larry Bird
West was a better defender. Bird was a better team player. As far as who was better I would say Bird.
Re: Jerry West or Larry Bird
-
- Assistant Coach
- Posts: 4,425
- And1: 2,661
- Joined: Apr 20, 2014
Re: Jerry West or Larry Bird
Larry Bird with a small but distinct lead for me. I do consider Jerry West to be the second best sg after MJ though.
If you're asking me who the Mavs best player is, I'd say Luka. A guy like Delon Wright probably rivals his impact though at this stage in his career. KP may as well if he gets his **** together.
GeorgeMarcus, 17/11/2019
GeorgeMarcus, 17/11/2019
Re: Jerry West or Larry Bird
-
- Assistant Coach
- Posts: 4,106
- And1: 1,498
- Joined: Aug 04, 2005
- Location: Estonia
Re: Jerry West or Larry Bird
Look at their per 100 numbers and you can see that these numbers paint the story that is far from the truth. Pace definitely needs to be factored in when comparing players 30-40 years apart from each other.leolozon wrote:Warspite wrote:Imagine if Kobe were a better shooter, rebounder, defender and passer and that is Jerry West.
I was going to say that this is stupid, but then I went to look at the stats and... well maybe.
Kobe 25ppg, 4.7 asts, 5.1rbds. TS% .550, WS/48 .170
West 27ppg, 6.7asts, 5.8 rbds, TS% .550, WS/48 .213
PER 100 numbers for West:
Kobe had much higher volume, his 2P% and FT% were considerably more higher and his rebounding numbers were also better (just see their TRB%: 8.1% vs 5.1%).
Better defender relatively to their eras ? Possible, but I love to watch old games and there's zero doubt in my mind that perimeter defense in the 60's and 70's (especially in the 60's) wasn't anywhere on the level it was when Kobe played. His only SPG numbers we have are from his last season but those are also inflated due to the higher pace and high SPG/BPG numbers do not reflect how good the player really was defensively or how good the offensive players were at protecting the ball from defenders.
We have even had some good debates over how good Walt Frazier really was defensively (best perimeter defender of his era) and it definitely has raised some doubts over how good even the best perimeter defenders at that time were. The eye test alone tells us that perimeter defense over the eras has gotten much better and I don't believe there is any reasonable argument against it.
I'll give him the passing but even that you can't say with any certainty.
If you don't believe me then you can see for yourself:
Re: Jerry West or Larry Bird
- Dr Positivity
- RealGM
- Posts: 59,906
- And1: 15,556
- Joined: Apr 29, 2009
Re: Jerry West or Larry Bird
It's probably closer than advertised. West is elite slasher (gets to FT line 9-10 times a game), was one of the best perimeter shooters in the league in an era where he didn't get help from the 3pt line, was usually 1st team all Defense from when they started giving it out. Averaging 2.6 steals and 0.7 blocks as a 35 year old in his last season could be reflective as the type of defensive numbers he may have put up in his prime. So he could do everything. Because of the minutes and pace he is not as high volume a scorer as Kobe is but he is a lot more efficient. West compared to his era in efficiency is more like a .63 TS%+ type of player now. He led the league twice in TS%. I see his volume/efficiency combination as being more like a Curry
Re: Jerry West or Larry Bird
- eminence
- RealGM
- Posts: 15,906
- And1: 10,810
- Joined: Mar 07, 2015
Re: Jerry West or Larry Bird
Blackfyre wrote:
Does anybody remember off the top of their head when they changed the foul rules to only be FTs on shooting fouls for the first however many fouls? Always strange watching the real old games and seeing guys go to the line on non-shooting fouls at the beginning of games.
I bought a boat.
Re: Jerry West or Larry Bird
-
- Lead Assistant
- Posts: 5,326
- And1: 1,605
- Joined: Jan 21, 2012
Re: Jerry West or Larry Bird
One interesting thing about West is that he claimed in one of his autobios that he was actually 6'4 rather than the 6'3 or even 6'2 he always listed as. That plus his great length, speed and quickness, leaping ability (he could touch the top of the square on the backboard from a two foot leap under the basket) made up for his slender physique went he first entered the NBA.
As to who would I take, that's a tough one. But maybe Bird. West said it took him eight or ten years before he fully understood how to play the pro game. Bird understood the pro game almost immediately.
West's athletic gifts were better respective of his position than Bird's. But Bird was a better athlete than some people believe. Watching some of his college games recently I'm struck by how quick and easily he maneuvered around the court to take control.He could have been an outstanding pro after his soph year in college.
Bird was a more skilled player than West, but West made up for his limitations with better athleticism. Both had killer desires to win.
As to who would I take, that's a tough one. But maybe Bird. West said it took him eight or ten years before he fully understood how to play the pro game. Bird understood the pro game almost immediately.
West's athletic gifts were better respective of his position than Bird's. But Bird was a better athlete than some people believe. Watching some of his college games recently I'm struck by how quick and easily he maneuvered around the court to take control.He could have been an outstanding pro after his soph year in college.
Bird was a more skilled player than West, but West made up for his limitations with better athleticism. Both had killer desires to win.
Re: Jerry West or Larry Bird
-
- Senior Mod - NBA Player Comparisons
- Posts: 28,492
- And1: 8,709
- Joined: Aug 14, 2004
- Location: South Florida
Re: Jerry West or Larry Bird
AmusingFiddle wrote:I grew up in the Larry Bird era and found him to be an absolute beast and merciless assassin on the court. The guy was a warrior and played thru many injuries while leading his team to championships.
Jerry West on the other had I have not watch play. The clips that I have seen of him, he seems very fluid almost timid. Comparatively, His numbers from what I understand are very impressive. Obviously he is the logo and one of the greatest ever for a reason.
Can any of you basketball savants shed some light on how you would compare the two and whom would you consider a better ball player?
Sent from my iPhone using RealGM mobile app
Timid seems a really odd word for a guy who had an Allen Iverson like rep for toughness going to the basket (and missing time with injuries) among contemporaries. Better known for his multiple broken noses than for being "timid."
“Most people use statistics like a drunk man uses a lamppost; more for support than illumination,” Andrew Lang.
Re: Jerry West or Larry Bird
-
- Forum Mod
- Posts: 11,878
- And1: 7,305
- Joined: Feb 24, 2013
Re: Jerry West or Larry Bird
Johnlac1 wrote:One interesting thing about West is that he claimed in one of his autobios that he was actually 6'4 rather than the 6'3 or even 6'2 he always listed as.
The origin of that listing is apparently from college at West Virginia, where [as an 18-year-old freshman] he was measured at 6'2" [without shoes, iirc], and so that height listing stuck throughout his career.
But yeah, here is next to DWade (who's listed at 6'4"):
And here a couple next to Kobe (listed 6'6"):
So it's pretty clear he'd be listed at least 6'4" today. Add to that he had sort of weird high-set shoulders (kinda like Kevin McHale) and pretty long reach; imo his effective length is more like a guy who's listed at 6'5" (or so) today.
"Never argue with an idiot. They will only bring you down to their level and beat you with experience." -George Carlin
"The fact that a proposition is absurd has never hindered those who wish to believe it." -Edward Rutherfurd
"The fact that a proposition is absurd has never hindered those who wish to believe it." -Edward Rutherfurd
Re: Jerry West or Larry Bird
- AmusingFiddle
- Rookie
- Posts: 1,092
- And1: 315
- Joined: Jun 17, 2008
Re: Jerry West or Larry Bird
bwgood77 wrote:AmusingFiddle wrote:I grew up in the Larry Bird era and found him to be an absolute beast and merciless assassin on the court. The guy was a warrior and played thru many injuries while leading his team to championships.
Jerry West on the other had I have not watch play. The clips that I have seen of him, he seems very fluid almost timid. Comparatively, His numbers from what I understand are very impressive. Obviously he is the logo and one of the greatest ever for a reason.
Can any of you basketball savants shed some light on how you would compare the two and whom would you consider a better ball player?
Sent from my iPhone using RealGM mobile app
Threads of this nature are better served on the Player Comparisons forum.
Will do.
Sent from my iPhone using RealGM mobile app
Re: Jerry West or Larry Bird
-
- Senior Mod
- Posts: 50,892
- And1: 19,581
- Joined: Mar 10, 2005
- Location: Cali
Re: Jerry West or Larry Bird
AmusingFiddle wrote:I grew up in the Larry Bird era and found him to be an absolute beast and merciless assassin on the court. The guy was a warrior and played thru many injuries while leading his team to championships.
Jerry West on the other had I have not watch play. The clips that I have seen of him, he seems very fluid almost timid. Comparatively, His numbers from what I understand are very impressive. Obviously he is the logo and one of the greatest ever for a reason.
Can any of you basketball savants shed some light on how you would compare the two and whom would you consider a better ball player?
Sent from my iPhone using RealGM mobile app
As you'll see in my sig below, I think very highly of both these guys.
I think that if they all played today, Jerry West might be the best of the players from the '60s. His skill set basically fits in with what we want from a guard today both on offense and on defense.
Where I think Bird has the edge over West though is in his off-ball genius. Bird's just unparalleled in reading the floor without the ball and figuring out what needs to happen next. Combine that with his amazing motor in his prime, his 3-point potential, and the simple fact that the dude is a big dude, I'd still take Bird over West.
Getting ready for the RealGM 100 on the PC Board
Come join the WNBA Board if you're a fan!
Come join the WNBA Board if you're a fan!
Re: Jerry West or Larry Bird
-
- Senior Mod - NBA Player Comparisons
- Posts: 28,492
- And1: 8,709
- Joined: Aug 14, 2004
- Location: South Florida
Re: Jerry West or Larry Bird
Doctor MJ wrote:AmusingFiddle wrote:I grew up in the Larry Bird era and found him to be an absolute beast and merciless assassin on the court. The guy was a warrior and played thru many injuries while leading his team to championships.
Jerry West on the other had I have not watch play. The clips that I have seen of him, he seems very fluid almost timid. Comparatively, His numbers from what I understand are very impressive. Obviously he is the logo and one of the greatest ever for a reason.
Can any of you basketball savants shed some light on how you would compare the two and whom would you consider a better ball player?
Sent from my iPhone using RealGM mobile app
As you'll see in my sig below, I think very highly of both these guys.
I think that if they all played today, Jerry West might be the best of the players from the '60s. His skill set basically fits in with what we want from a guard today both on offense and on defense.
Where I think Bird has the edge over West though is in his off-ball genius. Bird's just unparalleled in reading the floor without the ball and figuring out what needs to happen next. Combine that with his amazing motor in his prime, his 3-point potential, and the simple fact that the dude is a big dude, I'd still take Bird over West.
I would too because in today's systems, Bird is a stretch 4, which is a hard to find and vital link. As such, his offensive genius is maximized and his defensive limitations minimized. West would be superb in today's game as well but without knowing how his terrific shooting range would stretch to 3 point shooting, he's a more risky pick. If his range (probably best in league when playing) and efficiency (he and Oscar were the two greatest non-centers by a large percentage) translate relative to era, you end up with Harden's offense and Tony Allen's defense, arguably the greatest guard and potentially the greatest player in history. But, it's purely speculative. We KNOW how great Bird's 3 point shooting was and in a league like today's, we can much more easily predict the degree to which it would be more effectively utilized. So, I'd go with Bird but both would most likely be top 5 players in the league.
“Most people use statistics like a drunk man uses a lamppost; more for support than illumination,” Andrew Lang.
Re: Jerry West or Larry Bird
-
- Lead Assistant
- Posts: 5,326
- And1: 1,605
- Joined: Jan 21, 2012
Re: Jerry West or Larry Bird
A lot of footage people see of West's jump shot shows him shooting his famous quick release jumper which usually came off fairly flat. Since he usually shot off the dribble and rarely had catch and shoot situations, people mostly associate him with that shot. But he said when did get the occasional catch and shoot, he shot it differently from his off the dribble jump shot putting more arch on it. He had very good form, and I don't think he would have had much of a problem adapting to the three pt. shot.penbeast0 wrote:Doctor MJ wrote:AmusingFiddle wrote:I grew up in the Larry Bird era and found him to be an absolute beast and merciless assassin on the court. The guy was a warrior and played thru many injuries while leading his team to championships.
Jerry West on the other had I have not watch play. The clips that I have seen of him, he seems very fluid almost timid. Comparatively, His numbers from what I understand are very impressive. Obviously he is the logo and one of the greatest ever for a reason.
Can any of you basketball savants shed some light on how you would compare the two and whom would you consider a better ball player?
Sent from my iPhone using RealGM mobile app
As you'll see in my sig below, I think very highly of both these guys.
I think that if they all played today, Jerry West might be the best of the players from the '60s. His skill set basically fits in with what we want from a guard today both on offense and on defense.
Where I think Bird has the edge over West though is in his off-ball genius. Bird's just unparalleled in reading the floor without the ball and figuring out what needs to happen next. Combine that with his amazing motor in his prime, his 3-point potential, and the simple fact that the dude is a big dude, I'd still take Bird over West.
I would too because in today's systems, Bird is a stretch 4, which is a hard to find and vital link. As such, his offensive genius is maximized and his defensive limitations minimized. West would be superb in today's game as well but without knowing how his terrific shooting range would stretch to 3 point shooting, he's a more risky pick. If his range (probably best in league when playing) and efficiency (he and Oscar were the two greatest non-centers by a large percentage) translate relative to era, you end up with Harden's offense and Tony Allen's defense, arguably the greatest guard and potentially the greatest player in history. But, it's purely speculative. We KNOW how great Bird's 3 point shooting was and in a league like today's, we can much more easily predict the degree to which it would be more effectively utilized. So, I'd go with Bird but both would most likely be top 5 players in the league.
Re: Jerry West or Larry Bird
-
- Senior Mod - NBA Player Comparisons
- Posts: 28,492
- And1: 8,709
- Joined: Aug 14, 2004
- Location: South Florida
Re: Jerry West or Larry Bird
I don't either but there's a huge difference between adjusting to the era and becoming a 35% 3 point shooter on high volumes and becoming a 40% 3 point shooter on high volumes (or shooting it less like Wade).
“Most people use statistics like a drunk man uses a lamppost; more for support than illumination,” Andrew Lang.
Re: Jerry West or Larry Bird
- feyki
- Veteran
- Posts: 2,876
- And1: 448
- Joined: Aug 08, 2016
Re: Jerry West or Larry Bird
West was a better shooter first of all . Because it's their strongest aspect about the game . Bird was probably better defender cause he could defend on the perimeter(80-86) and also not often but he could defend in the post too . West was more like Kobe , had monster D on the perimeter but not as good as Kobe on the help defence .
Bird by far better rebounder . Probably better passer too . West wasn't like a real PG until in the Gail/West/Wilt big3 time . Cause they wanted running the offence from him . And he did it , btw .
West wasn't like Jordan-culture players type high volume scoring . But of course , he was a great scorer . Bird was too . If i have to choose one here , i say West .
As a player and more impactful player , Bird was better .
Bird by far better rebounder . Probably better passer too . West wasn't like a real PG until in the Gail/West/Wilt big3 time . Cause they wanted running the offence from him . And he did it , btw .
West wasn't like Jordan-culture players type high volume scoring . But of course , he was a great scorer . Bird was too . If i have to choose one here , i say West .
As a player and more impactful player , Bird was better .
“The idea is not to block every shot. The idea is to make your opponent believe that you might block every shot.”